| Navigation |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
“IS NON-VEGETARIAN FOOD PERMITTED? |
|
| |
“IS NON-VEGETARIAN FOOD PERMITTED OR PROHIBITED FOR THE HUMAN BEING?” – Part I
(Mr. Jayantilal Doshi) Mr. Y.P. Trivedi is a very senior advocate in Supreme Court of India, and leading tax expert of Mumbai. His activities in economic field, inside ex-president of Indian Mercantile Chambers and active members of Chairman of many other Institute, trade and industrial body. In professional field, he was president of Chambers of IT consultant, and Vice-President of IT Tribunal, and Bar Association. In political field, he is traders of Maha Pradesh Congress Committee BRCC. He is also Chairman and Director of many Public Limited Companies… Reliance and Dena Bank. In educational field, he was Stockation of matters, degree in lower, and Bombay University. He regularly continues article of various sinpident in different papers and Journalist. He has addressed a member of Senior, and meeting of Rotary Lion Club, etc. and Air India and Doordarshan, etc. - Thank You.
(Dr. Mohammed) Now we have Mr. Dhanraj Salecha, President of Rushabh Foundation, presenting momentous to our chief guest, as well as garlanding him on behalf of the organization.
Now we have our chief guest Mr. Y.P. Trivedi, addressing our audience collected here today - Mr. Y.P. Trivedi.
(Mr. Trivedi) Dr. Zakir Naik, Mr. Rashmi Zaveri, Dr. Mohammed Naik,
Dr. Dhanraj Salecha, Chimanlal Vohra, and friends - Before I give my introductory speech, I have been told and I think I would like to repeat, and say with great firmness… and one of the greatest friend and the greatest enemy of our civilization, is the cellular phone. And all those who have got cellular phones, it is a… it is a great friend, you know when you are in absolute necessity… and when you are in a meeting, it is a great enemy. So I would request all those with cellular phones, please switch off the phones and do not disturb, because it disturbs the trend of thinking of those who are speaking and those who are attending and others, listening very attentively. Friends, I welcome all the speakers and all of you here, to this very healthy debate which is taking place. I believe that this should be the beginning of similar debates, which should take place in the times to come. This debate or discussion, or the clearing house of mind, is probably in the best traditions… both of the Hindu civilization as well as of Islam . In our mythology and our history, we have such instances of such debates taking place in the courts of kings like Janak, when people from various shades of thoughts… because Hinduism was never following one particular pattern of thinking. There was Bhakti Marg, there was Non-Dualism, there was Advayit Marg, there was Charwaks… who did not believe in any God - so all of them, Janak King… King Janak used to assemble them, provoking them to debate - not trying to influence anybody, but inviting the thoughts, and then leaving the debate to the people at large, to make up their own minds. So that was the tradition of our Hindu religion in this land of India. That was also the tradition of Islam - In the immediately succeeding years after the demise of Prophet Mohammed, Islam was a religion - Arabia was the place which was the place of learning logic, Mathematics, Astronomy - all this was been discussed and the great scholars of Arabia, and built the thoughts, made inquiries and transformed that knowledge there after to the Western world. According to me the Renaissance Movement in Europe, owed its origin to the thinking of these Arab thinkers… who were great stalwarts in their own time.We very often associate Arabia, with thinking about, ‘Arabian Nights’. But let me tell you, that apart from the strides which they made in the field of fiction. And some of the most imaginative fictions, at the same time in the field of science, technology, thinking, logic, mathematics… they made great strides. That is why, today also, inspite of all their achievements, the West is still talking about the numerals, as the ‘Arabic numerals’ and this is how Islam also in those days used to think openly, that tradition had been continued - because I believe in the reign of King Akbar, he also used to call people from all Religions. Even the Christians who came at that time… they landed on the shore of India - They were also called, and they were asked to explain what are the tenets of the Religion. So this sort of a healthy debate is something which is an absolute necessity for the development of any cultured, civilized, and tolerant society. Dr. Vohra said that he is neutral - let me tell you, tell him, and all of you, I am also neutral. If I would not have been neutral, I would not have been made the chief guest. And I do not wish to desire to make any final comment on the subject… but one school of thought, I would like to narrate here, which I have read at some place - that all those animals… in nature, who are grass eaters, the animals which are thriving on leaves… they have got bovine teeth, they do not have canine teeth. All those animals which are eating flesh, meat eaters, they have got canine teeth… what we call ‘Rakshi’. Human being is the one specie, which has got both bovine teeth, as well as canine teeth. It is very likely, that nature wanted this specie to survive - Nature considered that this species… human beings, are the most important specie which should be there in this world. They should try to contribute… they should try to carry My message, and take it further. So they wanted… the nature probably wanted this specie to survive under all circumstances. Nobody can deny that the early Homo Sapiens or Homo erectus… they were all flesh eaters… at that time there was no agriculture… if you look at the evolution as we now learn from science. It is only the advance advance…. of civilization, that people started taking to agriculture. When they started taking to agriculture and started growing Corns… some of them became Vegetarians, some of them remained Non-Vegetarian, some of them became the mixture of both - they also took Vegetarian as well as Non-Vegetarian - and most of the Non-Vegetarian people today, also eat Vegetarian food as a part of the diet. I believe that in this aspect, when you are talking, whether it is permitted or prohibited - we are talking about permission or prohibition by the Religion. In this one aspect Dr. Naik, I would probably like to differ from you. I believe that it is not the function of Religion, to tell us, that… ‘What we should eat and what we should not eat’. Religion should try to purify our soul, purify our conscience, talk about good behavior, lead us to the path of God. What we should… what we should not eat, is something which the doctors should tell us… the nutrition experts should tells us. It is not the function of the Religion to say… ‘You shall not eat Garlic, you shall not eat Onions, you shall not eat Ginger’ because this is something, if subsequently the nutritional experts tell us, that this is something which is very good for your health, which is very good for your survival, which is very good for you to fight your diseases… then certainly it has to be taken. Because these are the subjects, in modern day’s science - We have to grow up, we have to think in terms of what is lying ahead of us - We are entering now the next millenium… 21st Century - So much is expected from us. Today only I was reading in one of the magazines, about the forecast of Nostradamus. That, Nostradamus thinks that this particular country, which is surrounded on three sides by sea… that one country will come on the top of the world. And are we going to go into the top of the world, become a super power, by just clinging ourselves to some of the outdated notions. For example, yesterday so many people migrated from this country - I was wondering in the heart of my heart… what is it?… there is no scientific explanation all through out. All people with any bases of logic, all people who knew something about science - they were saying… ‘Nothing will happen… whether eight planets come in one line or they go zig zag - nothing is going to happen’. But then all types of talks were there. ‘Alan’ which is our largest shipyard - that was completely forsaken and completely deserted - I was told that… for rushing to Rajasthan. I believe, I do not understand why people from Rajasthan are so panicky. The Marvadis left everything, came here, and made a empire - And the same Marvadis… thinking 8 planets are there… they ran away. I was told, 2500 rupees were paid for a bus ticket, for going back to Rajasthan, and nothing happened. So what is very important for all of us… if this country has to go further, if we as a nation, has to make our mark and probably the destiny before us… we can reach great strides. 21st centuries… as I have always been saying, belongs to India and Pakistan - both of them, when they will come near and near… they will be able to become the leaders of the 21st century. And if that is going to happen, then let me tell you, we will have to get out of these old dogmas. What we should eat… we should not eat - the doctors should tell us. If a new scientific discovery is made, and I have been asked, that I should eat tomatoes because it fights the cancerous growth, then I must eat tomatoes - irrespective of what my Religion tells me. So I think, let us go to the Scientists - let us develop for ourselves a modern mind… a scientific approach - then I think today or tomorrow, the whole world is before us. I do not want to comment on the… or trespass on the domains of the speakers. With this introductory remarks, I am once again trying to point out - I am absolutely neutral and I would like to hear the views of the learned people, who have made research on the subject - Thank very much.
(Dr. Mohammed) Thank you Mr. Trivedi… now we have brief introduction of each of the speakers, before we get into the mode of formal dialogue programme.
We have Mr. Chamanbhai Vohra, Senior Vice-President of the Indian Vegetarian Congress, to introduce Mr. Rashmibhai Zaveri.
(Mr. Chamanbhai Vohra) Well, today I feel very happy to introduce our President Shri. Rashmibhai Zaveri, President of the Indian Vegetarian Congress. I think this public dialogue will become very, very interesting, looking to the introductory speech given by our chief… learned guest, Y.P. Trivedi. So let us hope for the very good dialogue. Now Rashmibhai Zaveri is a Chartered Accountant by profession - He is having his own firm, ‘Rashmi Zaveri and Company’. They are very well reputed in the field of… as far as the Corporate sector section is concerned, and he is a very good speaker. As far as the Religious speeches are concerned, he is a master of many of the Religious philosophies. He is a very active member of the Chartered Accountant Society. He himself, is the member the of Bharat Jain Maha Mandal - He is the founder President of the Forum of Jain Intellectuals… one of very prominent institution, as for as the Jain people are concerned. And he is very well connected with the Kala Gujari also. Though he is very young at the age of 63, he is very energetic and he looks forward always to this type of dialogues - and today’s dialogue is really very good one. And I specially before… by giving the introduction of Mr. Rashmibhai Zaveri, I would like to thank our chief guest, as well as our Dhanrajji & our Zakir Naik Sahib, for having a very good dialogue… ‘Whether by principle, a human being can take, or should not take the Vegetarian and Non-Vegetarian foods’? - Thank you very much.
(Dr. Mohammed) Mr. Ashraf Mohammedy, to introduce Dr. Zakir Naik.
(Ashraf Mohammedy) Dr. Zakir Abdul Karim Naik, 33 years, is the President of the Islamic Research Foundation, Mumbai. Though a medical doctor by professional training, he is renowned as a dynamic international orator, on Islam and Comparative Religion. Dr. Zakir, removes misconceptions about Islam, on the basis of Qur’an, Hadith and Religious Scriptures of various other Religions. He also uses reason, logic and modern scientific facts, to remove the misconceptions about Islam. He is popular for his critical analysis and convincing answers, to challenging questions posed by audiences, after his public talks. In the last 3 years itself, he has delivered more than 300 public talks, world wide. Dr. Zakir also appears on various international TV and Satellite TV Channels, throughout the world. He has also participated in various symposia and such dialogues, with prominent personalities of various faiths.
(Dr. Mohammed) I have been asked by many persons… ‘Why are we having this dialogue - this topic, these speakers only?’ I here by clarify - Mr. Dhanraj Salecha, President of Rushabh Foundation, once visited the Islamic Research Foundation office, about one half month ago. He presented the Islamic Research Foundation kindly, with a set of literature favoring Vegetarianism. These included quotations from major world Religions, which included quotations also from the Qur’an, and sayings of Prophet Mohammed (peace be upon him), which according to him, indicate that Non-Vegetarian food is prohibited for human beings. After some discussions, Mr. Salecha proposed that a public dialogue be held at Patkar Hall… between Mr. Rashmibhai Zaveri, President of the Indian Vegetarian Congress and Dr. Zakir Naik, President of Islamic Research Foundation, on the topic…‘Is Non-Vegetarian Food Permitted or Prohibited for a human being’? This would in turn, enable the audience at large, to know the different view points of both the speakers, and form their own judgement. Both the speakers agreed to the same. Just about five days back, that is… this Tuesday. I met Mr. Zaveri, and he requested that both the speakers in their talk refrain form speaking on other Religions, except their own. Dr. Zakir, though being very ardently in the field of Comparative Religion, reluctantly agreed. Therefore, as far as the Religious points are concerned, in the talk and response of our speakers, Mr. Zaveri will speak only from the Jain viewpoint… unless compelled otherwise. Similarly, Dr. Zakir will speak only from the Islamic viewpoint… unless compelled otherwise. This in brief, is the clarifying background to the dialogue - the format for the dialogue will be, as agreed to, and decided fair by the speakers - Mr. Rashmibhai Zaveri will first address us for 50 minutes on the topic… ‘Is Non-Vegetarian Food Permitted Or Prohibited For A Human Being?’ Then, Dr. Zakir Naik will make his presentation for 50 minutes, on the same topic.
This would be followed by a response session, in which Mr. Zaveri will respond for 15 minutes, to the matter presented by Dr. Zakir. Similarly, Dr. Zakir too would then respond for 15 minutes, to the matter presented by Mr. Zaveri. When 5 minutes are left for the conclusion of the talk or the response time, I would put before each speaker, a ledge saying… ‘5 minutes left’ - in which time, they are expected to conclude. Lastly, we would have the question and answer session, in which the audience may pose questions to each of the speakers alternatively, on the question mikes provided in the auditorium. Written questions on slips of paper, would be given secondary preference… if time allows us. Now I would request our first speaker Mr. Rashmibhai Zaveri, to present his address. Ladies and gentlemen… Mr. Rashmibhai Zaveri.
(Mr. Zaveri) Before I start my talk, I am really very happy, that this atmosphere of brotherhood… it has really moved me, and I will request Dr. Zakir Naik to come forward and lets have a ‘Gale lag Ja scene’.
(Clapping)
The chief guest of this morning, Mr. Y.P. Trivedi, President of Rushabh Corporation, Shri. Dhanraj Salecha, the learned speaker Dr. Zakir Naik, the expert commentator and the coordinator, Dr. Mohammed Naik, Vice President of IVC Shri Chamanbhai Vohra, other dignitaries on and off the dais, my friends, brothers and sisters… First of all, I must acknowledge the dedication, the sincerity, with which all the three organizations, particularly Islamic Research Foundation, has taken pains in arranging this lecture. I do not mind and I do not hesitate in saying, the entire credit goes to IRF. Friends, the topic today is…‘Is Non-Veg. food permitted or prohibited for a human being?’ Any argument or any statement for that matter, is always to be considered from relative point of view. There cannot be any absolute truth, there cannot be any absolute statement, that it is 100% prohibited or 100% permitted. So friends, let us see, as very rightly put in by Mr. Trivedi, who has started the ball rolling… that we will not speak only from Religious point of view - Religious… has to enter… you can not diverse it from today’s subject. But I would like to speak on this topic, that… ‘Non-Veg. food is prohibited for human being’, from various angles. For example, Geographical reasons, historical reasons, Moral, Ethical and Religious reasons, Economical, Environmental and Ecological reasons, Natural reasons, and Psychological reasons, and above all medical reasons. It is a fact, now well established, that our actions are controlled by our thoughts.
What we think, we act… and our thoughts are controlled by our diet - As we eat, so we behave. And that is why, the topic is very important, that we should choose our diet in such a way, that our thinking is positive - the word positive will include everything. And believe me friends, not only all the Religions, but the medical science has now proved, that the food that we take, it definitely influences our thinking… and so our behavior. Friends, there was a time, when there was no alternative available, as Mr. Trivedi rightly put… there were places on this world, and there are even now places, where there is no availability of vegetation. It is simply not possible, because of the extreme circumstances. But now the world has progressed so much, that there is a very advanced system of transportation, which is available to us… and any type of commodity including food, can transported from one part of the globe to another, without any problem. Now… that when we have got alternatives, we have to think about this, which alternative is better, from all the angles - that which I have described earlier. And that is why friends, I am now coming to my topic proper that… ‘Non-Veg. food is not permitted’ now, at this point of time - not only for India, but for other countries of the world also. First of all, I will say that all Indian Philosophies have stated that we should not harm any living being, not only the living beings that we can see… but also those living beings, which we cannot see, which are in air, fire, water, etc. But always there is a limit - it is very difficult for a human being to refrain from total, total… ‘Hinsa’ or ‘violence’ because of his needs. So, that is why Lord Mahavir stated that… ‘At least you limit the essential killings, but absolutely no killing, for your own selfish motive or for your own needs of hunger, etc.’ And that is why under Jainism and most of the Indian philosophies, ‘Non-Veg. Food is totally prohibited’. Now this is our Religious aspect… I will not go very deep into it. But the psychological aspect… the effect that Non-Veg. food has on our thoughts and deeds… that is the most important part. The learned authors… I will not now quote the names of the books and authors, because that will take time, but I have got all the authorities with me. It is said that Veg. diet reduces needless suffering in the world, and also preserves our ecosystem. See, when I talk about alternative, you look here… you look at the wild animals who stay in jungle… they… those who are Carnivorous, they will restrict themselves to meat eating only - but those animals which are Herbivorous, they will never go for meat eating. Only human being is such… because of some false notions, I will say it has… the human being is been both… a Carnivorous and Herbivorous. As I said, if alternative is available, why should we go for unnecessary killing? The basic principle underlying this theory is non-violence, love and compassion for animals, birds, fish, etc… because flesh food falls in ‘Not Essential Category’ while Vegetarian food comes under ‘Essential Category’. Psychologically also… cruelty, instant impulses, urges, basic animal instincts, impatience, are all the necessary consequences of flesh food. By eating animal flesh, man will ingest all the animal instincts… the four basic animal instincts of food, fear, possessiveness and reproduction. These are there in man… I do not say ‘No’… but they are the basic instincts. - We have got a reasoning mind, we can rise above these basic instincts, we can control our impulses and urges, and become… then only we can become ‘super animals’ or ‘super beings’ - otherwise, human beings and animals… there is no difference at all. But man has additional quality called ‘Reasoning mind’, which is blunted by the influence of flesh food, and man becomes more like animal. The scientific reason for this, is that flesh is an integral part of animal body - it is full of ‘Tamasik’ value. There are three types of value… ‘Tamasik’, ‘Rajyasik’ and ‘Shartrik’. ‘Tamasik’ in short, is the brutal sense, or brutal instincts of the animal. A man becomes more like an animal… he is careless, he is cruel, he is ignorant… if he is eating the food, that is… the part of the bodies of the dead animals. The crime rate is higher, aggression is the natural consequences of flesh food. It distorts the thinking and reasoning. It is not only a problem by itself, but it creates many other problems like increase in crimes, cruelty, etc. The virtues like compassion, sharing, self control, are obliterated by the impact of flesh food. If we insist on treating animals more brutally, then our behavior will also become less human, and more brutal. I will quote one ‘Shayeri’, that what will happen if this animal instincts is so embedded in our heart… what will become of men… ‘Aadmi ke shakl se ab dar raha hai Aadmi - Aadmi ke shakl se ab dar raha hai Aadmi. Aadmi ko loot kar, Ghar bhar raha hai Aadmi … Aadmi hi marta hai - mar raha hai Aadmi. Aadmi hi marta hai - mar raha hai Aadmi… Samaj kuch aata nahin, kya kar raha hai Aadmi’. Friends, this is because the man has become an animal. He does not then distinguishes between… whether he is an animal or a human being, because this is the influence of the food, the flesh food that he eats. Flesh food is the cause of ‘PMS Syndrome’ - that is, ‘Pre Postures mood swings’ and psychological distortions - thus it is now established, that the flesh food is the root cause of moral and spiritual degeneration. We, at Indian Vegetarian Congress… we are working for important task, since it will lead to a more humane world at peace with animal kingdom, and with each other. We at ‘IVC’, define a ‘Vegetarian’, as one who does not, at any time, or under any circumstances eat meat, fish, fowl, eggs or any other type of flesh food. ‘Vegetarian’ does not come from ‘Vegetables’… now this very important friends, understand, the word ‘Vegetarian’ does not come from ‘Vegetable’. The root is, it is derived from the word Vegetus… V-e-g-e-t-u-s, meaning - whole, sound, fresh, lively - ‘Nothing is more powerful than an individual, acting out of his conscious, thus helping to bring the collective conscious to life’… that is, what Norman Consin said. And what does Albert Switzer has to say… ‘Until man extends his circle of compassion to all living things, man will not find peace for himself. It is a man’s sympathy with all creatures, that first makes him truly a human being’. Now friends I will go next, to the most important topic, and that is… the medical view point. It is a fallacy friends… it is a myth, to say that we do not get enough protein from Veg. food, and that is why a man must have a flesh food, that is rich in protein. I will come one by one, to these myths. First of all, I will first give you examples of those strong animals say elephant, say Rhino… these are the strongest animals on this earth. Are they meat eaters?… No, they are pure Veg. - Even if they die, they will not eat meat, even then they are the strongest. Take example of Horse… We talk about ‘Horse Power’ - it is the most powerful creature, useful for our purpose… and that is also a pure Vegetarian. And take examples of Cattle, Cows, Bullock and other animals… they are not only useful to us, but they are pure Vegetarian. My point here is, that those Vegetarian animals are strong enough, and they do not need any flesh food. In fact if stupidly, flesh food is given to these Veg. animals, what will happen? you all know about ‘The Mad Cow disease’, the syndrome called ‘BSE’. Friends, this ‘BSE’… ‘Bovine Spongephome Encyphalopathy’ - You know what happened a few years back in England. It was a result of feeding rendered Sheep bye products, to cattle, as protein supplement. This Sheep were infected with ‘Scrappy’ and ‘Acy’ disease, known for over two hundred years. Now if Sheep food can make a Cow mad, what do you expect the result on human beings? Millions of innocent Cows were killed mercilessly, just because they were suspected to be infected with ‘BSE’, and that too for no fault of theirs - but the stupid ways of feeding Sheep protein, on absolutely unnatural diet for a Cow. So is case with humans… animal protein is not natural for us. Similarly, millions of Chicks were destroyed in Eastern Asia countries, because they were infected with certain disease. Now coming back to healthy diet, I will quote from one Dr. Dean Ornish, who has written a very learned book on - ‘How to reverse heart disease, without surgery or drugs’. And this book, my friends, is the best seller in America now… it has really created interest in the people of America and all over the world, for that matter - that Veg. food is definitely better from medical point of view. He has given two types of diet - One reversal and one prevention of heart disease. Both are strictly Veg. diets - Because he has proved scientifically, that Veg. food is the best food, for a human being. It not only helps heart patients, but also reduces risks of other degenerating and fatal diseases caused by flesh food - disease like Cancers of Colon, Cancers of Breast, Cancers of Prostate, Obesity, High blood Pressure, Stroke, Diabetes, Gal stones. The Surgeon General of America has confirmed this, in the report on ‘Nutrition and Health’. He has given certain facts for proteins. Friends, we will have to little technical about it - the proteins is formed, from building blocks, called Amino Acids. These are of million varieties, of which, only three are critical for us… Lysine, Tryptophan and Mythiomine - all these are available in animals as well as Veg. plant food. But when one consumes animal food for getting these three critical Amino Acids - one also consumes unnecessary elements like cholesterol, saturated fat. Friends these are the two things that are the prime reasons - the killers for human beings - ‘Cholesterol’ and ‘Saturated fat’. Now let us address the issue that is universally put forward… ‘That we do not get sufficient protein from vegetarian food, and so we have to turn to flesh food, for adequate supply of Amino Acids’ - Now this is a fallacy. A combined meal of Legumes and Cereals Legumes means dal, pulses and cereals means Wheat, Rice, etc. You have to combine this two, and you get a complete balanced diet, which provides complete protein - which is not different from proteins found in eggs or meat - but without cholesterol and animal instincts. One diet, one Dietetic Association has stated, positive relationship between ‘Vegetable life style and risk reduction for several cronic degenerative diseases’ as mentioned earlier - It has confirmed that Veg. diet is healthier and more nutritious. Plant food is totally free from cholesterol, which is only found… it is… which is found in both… but cholesterol is only found in animal products such as meat, poultry, fish and diary. Flesh food is also high in saturated fats, which our liver converts into cholesterol - Our body makes all the cholesterol we need. Now this is very important friends, you must understand - We do not have to… we need cholesterol, but we do not have to take cholesterol from animal food - our body… it is a wonderful mechanism - the bio-chemistry, the chemical factory of our body can manufacture all proteins, all cholesterol, from our own systems. 3/4th of the cholesterol in our blood, is made by our body - it is the excessive amounts of cholesterol and fat in the diet, that lead to coronary heart disease. The other diseases friends, which I have summarized from various journals… Medical Journals - Epilepsy, Infected flesh, kidney diseases, excessive proteins, excessive Uric acid - these are all the diseases because of the flesh food - Rheumetoroid, Arthritis, Gaud… this is the direct consequences of Uric Acid found in flesh food - Degeneration of intestine, decay in Immunitive System. Dr. Deepak Chopra of America, has stated that our body is capable of living for more than hundred years, if we take proper care of it. Now look at the population in North Extreme, North region Eskimos - Now per force because no vegetation is available, they have to take flesh food, and the average life of an Eskimo, is only 30 years. All Non-Veg. food is devoid of Vitamin C and Vitamin A, which is naturally available in vegetables - ‘Avidin’ in eggs and other dangerous bacteria, are responsible for many skin diseases such as Exchema, Scabies, Leprosy, etc. Now I will give you a certain scientific facts - One medical study has proved that there are less heart diseases in Veg. people, than flesh eaters. Second - It is a well known fact that, not only in India, but even in advanced countries, there is no full proof system of medical exam of animals, before slaughtering - thus diseases carried by them are passed on to the humans who eat flesh food. Friends, you all know, that like human beings, the animals are also infected by diseases, and they are the carriers of the deadliest germs - and when these animals they die, and one eats that flesh, that diseases which were infected, and which were the part of the dead body of that animal, is again inherited by us. 9% of food poisoning cases, 90% of food poisoning cases are in flesh food eaters. When an animal or bird is brought to a slaughter house - now this is friends… which is again, it needs some explanation. If you have visited a slaughter house or a poultry, you will know this - when the animals are brought to the slaughter house, and when they know that they going to be slaughtered, the… the pain, the agony, the anguish, that runs in the system… it gives rise to ‘Adreline’ the hormone which mixes with the blood, and into the flesh. Now these instincts of fear, anguish, anger, despair - all negative points are then becoming part of the flesh food, and it passes on to the person who eats. And that is why, friends, I say that when one eats flesh food he becomes more like animal and less like a human being. I will now turn to the fallacy that… ‘Eggs are necessary for growing children, because they contain protein’. As I said excessive protein is more harmful than useful, and the protein that we find in pulses, in cereals is much more richer and natural, than the protein, the excessive proteins we find in animal food. Now I will give you the example of egg - Each egg weighs about 100 grams and has, 170 calories. It contains 13.6% of protein, as against that any dal or pulse will contains 24% of protein… much more than the egg of same weight - 100 grams. Egg will contain 13.3% saturated fat, while there is no saturated fat, or very little of 1% in Cereals and Pulses - 450 to 500 milligrams of cholesterol is contained in egg… One egg. Amino acid called ‘Milionine’ which destroys Vitamin B, large quantity of Sodium Salt - all these are part of the egg. And when one eats egg, he is then infected… his body is infected because of this excess protein, cholesterol and saturated fat - It does not contain any carbohydrates it does not contain any fibre. Friends, the medical science has now come up forward, and stated that for our digestion we must have fibre, and fibre is found only in Vegetable food, and not in the flesh food at all. Now, cost wise, I am only comparing the egg… now cost wise, for 1 gram of protein, the cost of egg is 4 to 5 times more than the pulses, Wheat or Soya bean. Cost of 100 calories - It is almost 10 times costlier than the pulses - thus, pulses, Wheat, etc. are not only cheaper, but they provide other important nutritions like vitamins, minerals, fibre, etc. Now let us take a look at the poultry farming - Now they call it ‘Poultry Farming’… it is a totally. I tell you sir, it is a Poultry factory… the way in which the birds are stored there - They have to climb upon one another to eat or drink, because there is not sufficient space. Even the poultry people, they say that… ‘This is our factory, and these are our merchandise, they are goods… Nothing but our products - We are not concerned whether they are living beings or not’. They are totally devoid of any compassion, any ‘Karuna’, and that is why these things are also reflected in the birds. The birds are stored like commodities. They are fed unnatural food and administered drugs which are harmful for humans, only to speed up their metabolism - So that they can produce more eggs. The poultry people are only interested in making profit, and the result of this, they die premature death. It effects physical as well as mental health… Intellectual and emotional growth. Egg is poison for children. Eggs begin to rot immediately, unless they are put in deep freeze - But when they are marketed, they are prone to be… to… to decay and disease faster. ‘Vegetable Egg’ is again a myth… It is a fallacy - No egg can be a ‘Vegetable Egg’- It is an animal product, and animal product only. It is definitely… it is definitely a animal product - It can never be called a vegetable item - It is a misnomer, it is a deception. Friends, I will now turn to the economical aspect - Now this also, I have studied from various journals… medical science, and more important… from the Statistics department of the government of India, and government of America, the U.K. government, etc. But I will not… that is why give the citations during my talk - but I will give you the summary. U.K. - the survey has stated… ‘The land required to produce the fodders, to feed the animals to obtain flesh food, is 14 times more than that required for vegetable diet, to feed man directly’. Because what happens… first you grow fodder, you feed it to the animals, and then you kill the animal for flesh food - and that is how your get you flesh food. But then if the same land is used for agriculture, for pulses and cereals… that same piece of land can support many more families - and here only few families can be supported by using this land for pasture. I have been given one statistics… ‘10 squares acres of land can support, 10 heads of human beings, or 10 heads of cattle for the whole year - but 10 heads of cattle for meat, cannot support even one single person throughout the year natural grass or pasture, can and grain crop, both genetically belong to grass family’. You see once the crop is harvested, what we have is Hassish for Stock. These are again the source of… excellent source of bio-chemical fertilizer or manure. Look how many crores of rupees, of our foreign exchange we are wasting on artificial fertilizer and chemical fertilizer, which we all know is extremely harmful to us. But because we are not able to get the natural manure, which we can get from cattle and animals we are destroying them. Foolishly destroying them for our own food, but we are not considering the fact that the manure that these animals produce, are much more economical, much more healthier, and much more useful to our country. It is now well known fact, that 16 kilogram of food grain are required to be fed to one animal, for forming one kilogram of meat. Thus by feeding animals led for slaughter, the country is deprived of vital food grains which can feed many, many more people - So not only for growing food, but also for pasture and for manure, we require land. The human… ‘The human Onkogene’ work done by Professor Will Bieng from Masachuchets - it has stated that… ‘To obtain one calorie of animal flesh, seven vegetable calories have to be spend’. Then the studies further shows that… ‘The land needed to graze one average animal, can sustain five average families’. Friends, I will not burden you with facts and figures, but the summary of all this is that it is very economical to feed people on Veg. diet, rather then on flesh food. Now let us take the other point of view of Economy, Ecology, Environment, Slaughter houses, etc. Production of animal flesh food require more land, more water, more food grains for feeding animals meant for slaughtering. Now this will again destroy, or rather disturb the balance of our ecology and our environment. Because the resources are always limited, we have to make best use of that - either we grow crops or we rare animals, for slaughtering. And look at the way the slaughter houses work… how they are maintained - It is simply a hygienic horror… the conditions are appalling and totally unsanitary, all over the world. Yesterday only, on internet I got a report from foreign countries, advanced countries of America and France… that the conditions of slaughter houses there also… it is reported as ‘Totally unsanitary’. I got a copy of White Papers, from Government Accountability project of America. ‘Fighting field on the kill floor - a matter of life and death for America’s family’. Slaughtering of animals, meat processing plants, and finally most unhygienic ways of transport, and sale of flesh food has made flesh food, totally unfit for human consumption. And do not think for a moment, that imported packaged, nicely packaged meat, or canned meat, is totally hygienic. No, my dear friends… that is also coming from those slaughter houses, where all these things which I have stated of medical science, will apply. Not only that, they add certain preservatives certain chemicals, certain additives, which will keeps the meat fresh. Environmental consciousness in India and abroad, has now driven many people to Vegetarianism. ‘Environment-friendly Veg. Foods’ are now available. The craze now in all over the world, is to go for ‘Environmental-friendly Veg. Food’, because it is considered friendly and healthy. The Green factories or Grass houses, are now exporting plant food including fruits, to those countries which cannot grow them because of climate. The transportation system has given a much better alternative for food choice. In fact, for developing nations like India, Government and NGOs should give more emphasis, on larger production of more export of plant food, which will solve the economic development of our country. Now look at the pollution… the pollution caused by legal and illegal slaughter houses is terrific. The discharge of affluence from even so called ‘Modern Abattoirs’ is in the open, and exposed to elements and public gaze. The carcasses of animals, the flow of blood, the horrible stench, etc., will add to the pollution, ecological balance. Utility of animal world for human welfare cannot be over emphasised… Both are inter dependent - Cows, Sheep, Fish, Frogs, etc., are much more useful to us alive, than dead- then why should we kill our friends and our helpers? To satisfy our taste buds, we should not be so much ungrateful my friends… to our lesser beings… we call them animals or birds. Look at the… look at it from another point of view of natural manure - I have already stated that the animals produce, much more natural and healthy manure, than the artificial manure. Artificial chemicals, manure, cost us dearly. Then again, I am coming back to our economic term - We are importing artificial chemicals, for manure purposes - that is again a drain on our exchequers. Friends, I will now briefly give you historical and geographical views, I have already touched upon it. Historically in certain dry areas, of miles and miles of desert, where no vegetable can ever grow… may be only food for survival was the animal food. Geographically I stated is, like Eskimos… it is… there was no alternative - but once we have got this better alternative, which is healthier, which is more economical, which is more eco friendly, why not go for such food? And friends, I will now go to the most important point, which will prove my point beyond any doubt… that why man is Vegetarian, by nature? I have got some 16 points here, are to compare - ‘How our body is build up’. As Mr. Trivedi has started the ball rolling in this fashion of… ‘Bovine teeth’, and ‘Non-Bovine teeth’. Teeth embeded: Now I will first say about Herbivorous. Teeth of Herbivorous animals are embedded in the jaws - short, blunt, close to one another. While in Carnivorous, they are sharp, pointed, long, and conical. The two or four teeth, that we have got - like some people say… they are like Dog animal - they are not for meat eating, but they are found also in Apes and the Chimpanzees, and which are which are fit for picking the fruits, and eating the fruits. The claws: no sharp nails for Herbivorous, they are fit to pluck fruits only - while in Carnivorous the sharp nails help in tearing apart the prey easily. Jaws and chewing habits: Jaws of a Herbivorous, will move up and down, left and right, that is in all directions, they swallow their food after chewing - while the Carnivorous, the lower jaw moves upwards and downwards only… they swallow their food without mastication. Now friends you go on comparing this - I will only say Herbivorous and Carnivorous… it is for you enlightened friends to see, how our human body and parts of our human body, will fit - whether it will fit with Herbivorous animals, or with Carnivorous animals. Tongue: the tongue of Herbivorous is quite smooth, while that of Carnivorous is very rough. Water drinking habit: that is a very important thing. My friend, Dr. Paras Dalal told me - he said that… ‘These Herbivorous animals… they drink water with lips by suction - while all the Carnivorous, they drink the water with the tongue… they lap up’. We do not do it - we always use our lips. Now come to the length of intestine: longer intestines are found in Herbivorous… about 4 times the body length - this cannot quickly expel the flesh food - while in Carnivorous… smaller size of intestine, almost equal to the body length, and helps to expel flesh food, before it gets contaminated. Liver and Kidney: smaller in proportion in Herbivorous, so they are unable to throw out waste material easily - while in Carnivorous… liver and kidney are longer in proportion so they can throw out waste material easily. Digestive system: There is less Hydrochloric acid in digestive system of Herbivorous, thus flesh cannot be digested easily, while obviously in Carnivorous, the quantum of Hydrochloric acid is much more, and that is why they can digest the flesh food - but human being cannot. Saliva: In Herbivorous like human being, the saliva is alkaline and contains Vitaline which helps in digesting Carbohydrates, found in the grains - while in Carnivorous, there is… the saliva is always acidic. The blood: Ph is alkaline, like human being in Herbivorous - and acidic in Carnivorous. The blood… blood lipoproteins: - human blood lipoproteins is similar to all Herbivorous, while it is not similar to that of Carnivorous. Sense: Sense is weak - all the senses, particularly the eyesight is weak in Herbivorous, and very powerful in Carnivorous. Sound: The voice is not… the Herbivorous sound or even the human sound is not frightening, unless of course, we can make it now frightening… but by nature the sound of all Herbivorous is mild - while that of Carnivorous like Lions and Tigers is very coarse, and frightening. And lastly, Infants: Normal sight power of - right from - now see the young ones of Herbivorous - right from the moment of birth, they can see very clearly - while all the infants of Carnivorous wild animals are blind at least for a weak. Now friends it is for you to justify, whether man fits by nature in this category of Herbivorous… grain eaters, or in the category Carnivorous… the flesh eaters. Now friends, I will now tell you about certain great persons, who condemned flesh food. Looking at the world’s history, we find that all great Scholars, Philosophers, Scientists like Einstein, - Artists like Leonardo-da-Vinci, Poets like Milton Pope Shelly, and Writers like George Bernard Shaw, and Religious leaders of course, of the world - Now who are those people… the Mathematician, the Pythagorean, the Plutar, Newton and Einstein the Scientist, Dr. Annie Besant, Reverned Dr. Walter Walsh, George Bernard Shaw, Tolstoy, the Greek Philosopher Socrates and Aristotle - They are all enlightened people, and they say… they say that… ‘Blessed are those with noble qualities of tolerance and compassion, love and non-violence, who are not flesh eaters’. Now friends, I will quote from George Bernard Shaw, which is very famous and widely published…‘We are living graves of murdered beasts’ - listen what he says …‘We are living graves, moving graves of murdered beasts, slaughtered to satisfy our appetites - like Carrion Crows we live and feed on meat, regardless of the sufferings and the pain’. Doctors once advised Bernard Shaw… he was very ill - He said that… ‘You must take some meat soup’. Bernard Shaw said… ‘I will prefer death, than to have anything with flesh food’ and believe me friends, he survived… and the doctor turned ‘Vegetarian’. In the similar way, Mahatma Gandhi… his son was very sick - he was advised meat soup… and he refused - and the son survived. Why I am telling you friends all these things that, Mr. Trivedi said… ‘Yes, medically whatever that doctor says, we have to accept’. No doubt - but as I said in the very first thing… in the beginning I said… ‘Everything is relative’. When doctor says something, he will say only from medical point of view - and friends we are not living here… we are here on this earth, not only to survive - Survival is important, but not at the cost of others and inflict pain on others. Thank you very much friends. 21st century will belong to Vegetarians. Okay, I think I have made my point on very general terms, friends. I will tell you, that I know those who are regularly flesh eaters, are coming from some culture, some family, some faith, and that is why, they have never applied their mind. And that is what Mr. Trivedi stated, that let us… we are here today… we have gathered here… let us apply our mind, that not only from Religious angle, or from our social angle. Even I have seen I…I… I do not… I am not afraid to say, that many of our Jain friends, when they go to certain gatherings, because they are afraid of the social status, they start eating meat - I do not like it. But then, it is for everybody - whether he is a Vegetarian or a Non-Vegetarian, apply your mind - try to see from all these angles, whether it is permitted or prohibited, from our own health point of view, from the National point of view from the Social point of view, from Ecological, from Environmental, and above all, from compassion point of view. Friends, when nature has created all animals, all humans all creatures equal, nobody has got right to kill anybody, just to satisfy his own palate - Thank you very much.
(Clapping)
(Dr. Mohammed) Ladies and gentlemen… Dr. Zakir Naik to present his talk.
(Dr. Zakir) … (Arabic) …
Respected Mr. Rashmibhai Zaveri, Mr. Trivedi, Dr. Mohammed Naik, the respected people on the dais, my respected elders, and my dear brothers and sisters. I welcome all of you with the Islamic greetings… ‘Assalomo Alaykum Wa Rahmatulahi Wa Barakatuhu’. May Peace, Mercy and Blessings of Allah (SWT)… Almighty God, be on all of you. The topic of this morning’s debate is… ‘Is Non-Vegetarian food permitted or prohibited for a human being?’ It is not… ‘Whether Vegetarian food or Non-Vegetarian food - which is healthy or which is better?’ If I prove that ‘an Apple’ is better than ‘a Mango’… that does not mean ‘Mango’, is prohibited. This statement is sufficient to end the dialogue for me, but I have to reply. Non-Vegetarian, by definition means - ‘A person who has food of animal origin’. It does not mean… ‘A person who does not have Vegetarian food… it does not mean, a person who does not have vegetable and fruits.’ Let it be very clear to all of you. A more technical and a scientific word is, ‘an Omnivorous diet’. A person who has many types of food, especially foods of plant and animal origin. ‘Vegetarian’, as Mr. Rashmibhai Zaveri rightly said, it does not come from the word ‘Vegetables’- it comes from ‘Vegetas’ which means…‘ full of breath, full of life’ - he did not give a better explanation. We can talk about it - and he did not speak… there are various types of ‘Vegetarians’. We have ‘Fructorians’, who only eat fruits and nuts - then we have the ‘Vedanta’, who do not have any animal products - we have ‘Lacto Vegetarian’, what I believe Mr. Rashmibhai Zaveri is… they have milk, we have the ‘Ovo Vegetarians’ who have eggs - We have the ‘Lacto-Ovo Vegetarians’, who have egg and milk also - We have the ‘Pesco Vegetarians’ who eat fish. We have ‘Semi Vegetarians’ who also have Chicken. This classification is done by the Vegetarian Society… not by me - And you can name another 20, time does not permit me. I would like to state a quotation by Dr. William T. Jarves. Dr. William T. Jarves, he is the advisor to the ‘American Council of Science and Health’ ‘ACSH’, and he is also the ‘Professor of Public Health and Preventive Medicine’ in the Lomalinda University, and he is also the founder and the President of the ‘National Council Against Health Frauds’, and he is the co-editor of the book ‘The Health Robbers - a closer look at Ouakery in America’ - Most of the quotations he gives… from America. And according to him, he classifies ‘Vegetarian’ based on the behavior’s stand point, into two categories… ‘Pragmatic Vegetarian’ and ‘Ideological Vegetarian’. ‘A Pragmatic Vegetarian’ chooses his diet on objective health reasons - He is more reasonable in his approach, rather than emotional. ‘The Ideological Vegetarian’ on a other hand, he chooses his diet based on a principle, which is based on ideology - he is more emotional, rather than reasonable. And Dr. William T. Jarves says… ‘One can spot an Ideological Vegetarian, by his exaggeration of the benefits of Vegetarianism, and you could see that in the talk which preceded my talk… exaggeration of benefits of Vegetarianism. And the lack of skepticism, and the over looking of the fact that extreme Vegetarianism, can lead to potential health risk’. He says that…‘The ideological Vegetarian… he pretends to be like a scientist, but he is more like a lawyer, than like scientist’ - and you could see that in the talk by the learned speaker, more like a lawyer than like a scientist. They gather data information selectively, against the information which is against the ideology. This may be good for a debate like the one we are having, but not for engendering… scientific understanding. Dr. William T. Jarves says that... ‘Ideological Vegetarianism’ is filled with hypothesis - It is filled with extremism, from which even scientists and doctors are not immune’. And that you can see the quotation - Mr. Rashmibhai Zaveri has said, several diseases, and it is possible for me to refute each and every… but if time permits. Talking about science… but the approach was not scientific. All can be prevented very well - ‘Prevention is better than cure’… is the base of the medicine - which time will not permit me to go into health, and etc. In the rebuttal, if time permits I will try and cover most of the other aspects - and ‘Health’… I will try and cover in the rebuttal. Let us analyze the various reasons, why a person chooses a food habit. It can be Religious, it can be Geographical location, it can be a personal choice, smell, taste, colour’. Due to humane or ethical consideration, due to anatomical and physiological consideration, due to behavioral consideration, it can be due to ecological and economical consideration, it can be due to nutritional value or due to health and scientific reasons… health and medical reasons. Let us first analyze the Religious reasons - Mr. Trivedi said that… ‘Religion should not interfere with the human being… where it is concerned, what we should, and what we should not eat - That we should leave it up to the doctor’. I agree with him that most of the Religions, that is in the case. The Religious authority, the main foundation… that is Almighty God, if He is not a doctor, the God that you worship is not a doctor, then you should not follow him - He says… ‘Leave it to the doctor’. But in Islam, we believe… Allah (SWT), Almighty God, is our Creator - and the Creator of the human beings has far Superior knowledge, than all the doctors put together, in all the years. And you can find the statement, as Mr. Rashmibhai Zaveri said… ‘All from doctors’ - he is quoting from these books, which I think is available for sale outside… all these books. I will touch on some of these points, all out of which many are fictitious… fictitious, do not exist at all - Some are irrelevant, some are untested and some are truth… which are half-baked. I would like to make one point crystal clear, that while I prove undoubtedly, that Non-Veg. food should be permitted for the human beings, I do not have the slightest intention to hurt the feelings of any Vegetarian. And while I prove logically and scientifically that Non-Veg. food is permitted, and if someone feels hurt, his sentiments are hurt… I apologize in advance… I sincerely apologize. My intention is not to hurt anybody’s feelings, but I have to reply to the presentation, to the earlier speaker. As far as Islam is concerned, it is not compulsory for a human being to have Non-Veg. - a Muslim can be a very good Muslim, even by being a pure Vegetarian. But… but when our Creator… Almighty God… Allah (SWT), gives us permission to have Non-Veg., why should we not have it? And I started my talk by giving a quotation from the Glorious Qur’an, from Surah Maidah, Ch. No. 5, Verse No. 1, which says… (Arabic )…. ‘Fulfill all your obligations and lawful for you for food are. All four footed animals with the exceptions named’. Qur’an further says in Surah Nahl, Ch. No. 16, V. No. 5… ‘that cattle has been created by God, for you - in it are various benefits…. - You derive warmth, and of their meat you can eat’. The same message is repeated in Surah Mominun, Ch. 23, V. No. 21… ‘that you can have the meat of the cattle’. Let us analyze the geographical reasons and the surrounding environment… and as we know, it influences is the person’s food habit - like people living in the coastal region … the Kookiness, they have more fish - People living in South India, they have more Rice - People living in the desert, where there is scarcity of vegetation, and people mainly survive on the flesh of animals. The Eskimo in the Arctic region, where there is scarcity of edible vegetation, they survive more on sea food. And Mr. Zaveri said that…‘he knows that vegetable is not available in certain parts of the world, but today, due to advancement of transportation, we can supply them with vegetables’. I would request the Indian Vegetarian Congress to supply, at least give the transportation cost… that is all… to supply to the Eskimos, to supply to Saudi Arabia. You get vegetables in Saudi Arabia, it is more expensive… Why? … because the cost of transportation - that makes if more expensive. It is illogical and unscientific to spend more money, to buy a food which is less nutritious. Let us analyze the ‘Humane reason’, the ‘Ethical reasons’ - And the pure Vegetarians, they say that… ‘All life is sacred - and no living creature should be killed’. They fail to realize that today, it is a universal fact, that even plants have got life - So the main argument on killing living creature, does not hold good today. Previously may be… a couple of centuries ago, it may have held some weight, but today it carries no weight. Then they further argue today, and they say… ‘Yes we know that plants have got life, but they cannot feel pain… therefore killing a plant, is a lesser crime and lesser sin, as compared to killing an animal’. Today, science has further advanced, and we have come to know that even the plants can feel pain, they can even cry - But the cry of the plant cannot be heard by the human ear, because the audible frequency range of the human ear, is from 20 cycles per second, to 20,000 cycles per second - Anything below and above this, the human ear cannot hear.
(Clapping)
But the cry of the animal can be heard by the human being - but the cry of the plant cannot be heard by the human being - Just because you cannot hear the cry of the plant, that does not justify you to inflict pain or kill the plant. There was an ideological Vegetarian, who had a discussion with me, and he told me that… ‘Brother Zakir, I know the plants have life, they feel pain… but you know plants… they have got about two senses less, as compared to the animals’. I said… ‘For the sake of argument I agree with you’. But then I asked him a simple question, that… ‘Suppose your brother is born deaf and dumb - cannot hear, cannot speak - two senses less - and when he grows up, and when someone comes and murders him - will you go and tell the Judge…‘ O my Lord give the murderer a less punishment, because my brother had two senses less’. In fact he will say… ‘Usne to Masoom ko mara hai’… ‘He has killed an innocent person - give him a bigger punishment’. And further if you analyze that in Islam, as far as living creatures are concerned - they are two types… broadly classified in two types - ‘Human beings who are living creatures’- and Non-human being living creatures. As far as killing the human beings are concerned, Qur’an says in Surah Maidah, Ch. No. 5, Verse No. 32 that… ‘If any person - if any one kills any human being, unless if be for murder or for spreading mischief in the land, it is as though he has killed the whole of humanity and if any saves an human being, it is as though he has saved the whole nation’. If any person kills any human being… Muslim or Non-Muslim, unless if it be for murder or for creating mischief, Qur’an says… ‘He has killed whole of humanity - if you save any human being, you have saved the whole of humanity’. As far as non-human being living creatures are concerned, no human being should harm them unnecessarily… should not kill them unnecessarily… for sports, or for fun, or for target practice - but if it is for you security and for your safety, you can stop them, you can even kill them - or if you want for lawful food, but not just for fun and frolic, or for hunting. Even if I agree that the plants are a lesser species, as compared to the human beings - if you take the life of one animal… an average animal, it can feed about hundred human beings. For this same hundred human beings, you may have to kill more than hundred plants. So is it preferable to take the life of one living animal, or the life of 100 living plants?… Which is a bigger sin? …Is it a bigger sin to kill human beings who are handicapped, or kill one healthy human being… which is a bigger sin? - You decide for yourself. There is a Vegetarian Society by the name of ‘World Foundation on Reverence for all Life’… Most of the quotations which he gave, is from here and from these three books… most of them … all most all. The name of the foundation is ‘World Foundation as Reverence for all Life’- they forgot to mention… (except plant life) in bracket. And it says… ‘All creation is one family… All life is sacred’. What kind of an ideology is this, that you permit the killing of one family member, but do not permit the killing of the another family member? - It is illogical and unscientific. You know in America, there are Vegetarian societies who take students to slaughter houses, and they make them see the blood shed and convert them to Vegetarianism. It is like a doctor taking the young girls to observe and watch a difficult childbirth, and then say that… ‘Is the reason you should not marry, and you should not have children’. These are unethical forms of mind control - unethical…unethical. In fact we should teach our children that… ‘When vegetables can be grown for food, why cannot animals be raised for food?’ All life is sacred… I agree… Unnecessarily killing them is wrong - But for your requirement, lawful food is permitted. Let us analyze the anatomical and the behavioral consideration, and there were a list of various things mentioned by Mr. Zaveri - you know he was reading from paper at 100 miles per hour, I was trying to note down, note down, note down how many diseases… diseases I being an medical doctor can answer… but how much can I answer? To name ten diseases, will taken few seconds - To reply all ten will take more then an hour - And he had listed a lot. I will just try and tell you, that if you go to authentic books… authentic books - not researches made by Ideological Vegetarians… most of the answers are given on the medical aspect. Considering the anatomical and the physiological aspect… and he had rightly said, that… ‘If you observe the teeth of the Herbivorous animals the Cow, the Goat, the Sheep, they have a flat set of teeth… they only have vegetables. If you observe the teeth of the Carnivorous animals Lion, Tiger, Leopard, they hare pointed set of teeth… they only have animal flesh - Not Non-Veg. Animal flesh’ - They are not called as Non-Veg. animals, they are called as Carnivorous animals. There is a difference between ‘Carnivorous’ and ‘Non-Veg.’ - Non-Veg. actually is, ‘Omnivorous.’ But if you analyze the set of teeth of the human being, have got flat teeth, as well as pointed teeth. If Almighty God… our Creator, wanted us to have only vegetables, why did He give us these pointed teeth - for what? And Mr. Zaveri said… ‘These pointed teeth, they are not referring to the Dog - they refer to the Apes’. He does not know the scientific meaning of the word - ‘Canine’ comes from the root word ‘Cananas’, in Latin, which means ‘of Dog’ - and ‘Canine’ means pertaining to the family of Canada, like Wolves, Dogs, etc. - Scientists have given this name… ‘Canine’, meaning ‘pertaining to Dog’. And he said… ‘It does not look like the teeth of Dog - it refers to teeth of Apes and Monkeys’. I believe in agreeing with the argument and proving the point, than to disprove him - It is easy. Even if I agree… ‘It is the teeth like the Monkeys’… do you know Monkeys also have Non-Veg.? they have the Lice! - There are many species of Apes, who even have raw flesh of animals. Many species of Apes who have raw flesh… they are Omnivorous - Who says they are Carnivorous?… they are Omnivorous… they are not pure Veg. also. And many species are even called as ‘Cannibals’ - Some species of Apes and Monkeys. If you analyze the digestive system of the human being, it can digest both Veg. as well as Non-Veg. If Almighty God wanted us to have only vegetables, why did He give us the digestion system, which can digest both, Veg. as well as Non-Veg. And Mr. Zaveri said that we cannot have raw flesh - I agree with him… most human beings cannot have raw flesh. In the same way, most of the human beings cannot have raw vegetables, raw vegetarian diet, like raw Wheat, raw Rice… Can you have it? … raw Moong, raw Drumstick … Can you have? … You will get indigestion. So what is the argument? - No… no, you have to cook them. I know as a medical doctor, that raw Wheat, raw Rice, raw Drumstick if you have… you will have problem, you cannot digest them - So you have to cook them. Similarly with the flesh, we Non-Vegetarians, we cook them for easy digestion. But yet there are certain human beings, who even have raw meat. He gave the name of ‘Eskimo’… he did not tell the root word meaning - The root word meaning of ‘Eskimo’, it literally means ‘Eaters of raw flesh’. So there are human beings who even have raw meat… they are conditioned - Tomorrow if you are conditioned to eat raw Wheat and raw Rice, even you may be able to digest it. But most human beings cannot digest certain raw vegetables - That does not mean you should not have Rice, you should have Wheat, that you should not have Drumsticks. There are in the Herbivorous animals, an enzyme known as ‘Cellulaze Enzyme’ and every vegetable has ‘Cellulaze’ - and this Cellulaze enzyme, helps in digesting the vegetables. We human beings, we do not have ‘Cellulaze enzymes’… therefore the vegetables we eat, the cellulose part remains undigested and you call them as ‘Fibres’ - It is undigested. On the other hand, there are certain enzymes like Lipase, Trapezes, Kino Trapezes, which are mainly meant for digesting Non-Vegetarian food. If Almighty God, did not want us to have Non-Veg. food, why did He give all these enzymes? And the primitive man, as said by the earlier speaker as well as the chief guest… Archeological evidence shows us clearly… the Homo Sapiens, the Eskimos, the Austo Aborigines, they were Non-Veg. So why the change now?… We have the same teeth, we have the same digestive system. And he has given a list of other comparison, which prove we can have Veg…. and I agree with that - where did I ever say, that you cannot have Veg.? A Non-Veg., is a person who has the food of the animal products, as well as Vegetarian food - it is an Omnivorous diet. He said that the liver and the kidney in Carnivorous animals is large. In the human beings it is small like the Herbivorous, because the animals have raw meat… therefore they have to remove the toxins on a higher level - we do it by cooking the food. Therefore, God gave us a small kidney, and a small liver, which is sufficient to digest both, cooked Non-Veg. and also vegetables. Similarly with all the arguments… HCL… It is not very acidic… Why? - Because we do not require it. If you do not require it, why should God unnecessarily give to us? Same with saliva, same with the Ph of the blood, same with the Lipo-protein… all the arguments are, that because they have raw flesh, therefore they required it - We do not require it so why should God give us? Yes! It is required for digesting Veg. food, and cooked Non-Veg. food. He said… ‘Carnivorous, they lick, and the Herbivorous animal they sip’. We human beings, we do both… we do both - When we drink… while we drink, we sip - When we have ice cream what we do?… we lick. We lick also, and we sip also… depending upon what is the food we are eating. Even the tea we can lick… not that we cannot lick… but why to waste time? - It will take more time. Similar by with all the arguments he has given about… ‘the teeth being close’ because we also have vegetables. If God would have asked us not to have vegetables, then may be our teeth would have been far apart - He asked us to have both Non-Veg. as well as Veg. food. And there are various verses in the Qur’an, talking about various foods, Pomegranates, talking about vegetables, talking about Dates, etc., which we should have. The plants - many Vegetarians say… ‘That they re grow, therefore we are not killing the plants’- and there are some plants which have that facility, not all plants - ‘There are various, which we cut, it re grows’… See this is the only argument, that because it re grows, you can have Veg. food. You know if you cut the tail of the Lizard, it re grows - Will you have the tail of the Lizard? - It is a delicacy. There are human beings… the ‘Australian Aborigines’… they relish the Lizard - Will you have the tail of the Lizard? - And the answer will be… ‘ No.’ You know what I am doing now? I am behaving like a lawyer. I am feeling ashamed to answer all these things, but I have to do because it is also a debate. I had come here, so that we understand better, and have a friendly understanding of each other, but I have to behave like a lawyer also, besides being logical and scientific, because of the argument put forth. Any one who has general knowledge can reply... but because people do not have general knowledge - Many people are not aware… that is why these arguments may satisfy many people. And all these arguments are given in the books which are distributed… ‘Meat eating, 100 facts’ by Nemichand, distributed by Jain organization - also by the Indian Vegetarian Congress. These are the books given to me by Mr. Zaveri… ‘100 facts about Egg’, ‘Vegetarian or Non-Vegetarian’… Each and every argument, each and every argument can be disproved - Certain things I know… that Non-Veg causes diseases, which can be prevented. Let us analyze the ‘Behavioral consideration’ - He gave certain arguments… ‘The food we eat, has an effect on our behavior’- I agree with him to a certain level. The food we eat, has an effect on our behavior - That is the reason, we Muslims have flesh of Herbivorous animals like Goat, Sheep, who are docile and peace loving - We want to be peace loving and docile. We do not have the meat of the Carnivorous animals like Lion, Tiger, Dog, Pig, etc. - and the Prophet clearly says, all these animals are prohibited. We are peace loving people, therefore we want to have animals which are peaceful. And countering your argument… ‘You all eat plants, and you all behave like plants’… that is, suppression of the senses… a lower species - I know scientifically it is wrong… I am only behaving like a lawyer - I feel ashamed to speak these points, as a medical doctor. It is not true, that if you eat plants, you behave like plants - But the argument he has put forth… I am giving a counter reply … ‘You eat plants and behave like plants, weak and suppressed - cannot move properly’. I am sorry, I really apologize… I apologize - I have to reply to the arguments - I apologize if I have hurt the feeling of any Vegetarian. It is not scientifically true - It is just an argument… A counter argument. Further, he gave the list of various peace loving people like Mahatma Gandhi… and I respect Mahatma Gandhi, because he has done certain good things for India, and humanity. But if, because Mahatma Gandhi was peaceful, indicates, that if you have Veg.food, makes you peaceful… then today if you analyze the list of the Noble prize winners for peace, almost all, or most of them are Non.Vegetarians… Manekchang Began… Non-Veg., Yaseer Arafat… Non-Veg., Anwar Sadat… Non-Veg., Mother Teresa… Non-Veg.,… Mother Teresa. I want to ask you a simple question… ‘Which man in the history of human kind, is known maximum, for killing maximum human beings - Can you guess?’ Hitler… Adolf Hitler!… He has killed six million Jews - Was he a Non-Veg. or Veg.?… Vegetarian! Anyhow, there are crusaders of Vegetarians - you know… now in the internet if you go, they say… ‘See, Adolf Hitler was a Vegetarian… is a myth - He sometimes had Non-Veg.’. And the other side says that… ‘You know, when he had gastric problems, that time he had vegetable foods only’. To tell you frankly on a scientific viewpoint, I do not consider the diet of Hitler to be responsible for him killing six million Jews. Neither am I telling… irrespective whether he was a Vegetarian or Non-Vegetarian, I am not interested in knowing, because I being a doctor, I know it does not carry any weight. There were other factors which influenced him to take this drastic step, which is totally inhuman, not the diet. There are various researches done - there have been researches in America on a group of students, who were ‘Pure Non-Veg.’ and on group of students who were ‘Veg. … Pure Veg.’ And they analyzed that the group of students who were ‘Non-Veg.’… they were less violent, and they were more social - But it is a research… It is not a scientific fact. I will never use this as an argument to prove that Non-Veg. food makes you peaceful… No… I am a doctor… more of a doctor, as well as lawyer where required… because I am in a debate. There are ‘Researches’- but these ‘Researches’… are not ‘Scientific Facts’. Most of the statements what Mr. Rashmi Zaveri made - all were ‘Researches’… not ‘Scientific Facts’. There is not a single authentic medical book which says that… ‘Non-Veg. food in general should be prohibited’ - Not a single. All these are Researches - like the research done by this person in America. Then they say that… ‘Veg. food makes a person intelligent’ - and he gave a list of great names… Albert Einstein, Isaac Newton, etc., etc. If we analyze the list of the Noble Prize winners in all these years, majority were the Non-Veg. … Majority! And today ‘Animal Behavioral’ scientists - they say, that ‘the carnivorous animal, should be more intelligent than the herbivorous animal, in order to catch the prey - If he is not intelligent, how will he catch the prey?’ But anyway, I am not going to use this as an argument… ‘Therefore Non-Veg. food makes you intelligent’ - because these things do not actually effect a human being. The diet does effect human beings, but these are arguments… do not effect… these arguments do not effect - And all the other arguments given, they do not carry weight actually. There are people who give examples that… ‘Non-Veg. food makes you strong’ - is a myth. It is a scientific fact mentioned in every medical book… Authentic - That… ‘Non-Veg. food is good for health’. It does have diseases also… you can prevent them - There are proteins, which I will come to it later on. And to counter argue that, they are giving example of, ‘Yadunath Singh Naik’ - Has any body heard of him? - ‘Yadunath Singh Naik’… in the army. It is mentioned in the book ‘Vegetarian or Non Vegetarian - Choose for yourself ’, by Gopinath Agarwal -Yadunath Naik being a Vegetarian in the army, in wrestling, he defeated two Non-Vegetarians - therefore Veg. food makes you strong. I feel ashamed to reply to this argument… I feel ashamed. It is a known fact that the title holders of world wrestling… Yes, there are Vegetarian wrestlers also… but if you compare with the full world, almost all the title holders of world wrestling, are Non-Veg. The person known in body building… maximum… Who is he? - Arnold Schwarzneger! Thirteen times world titles, he got - Seven as Mr. Olmpia, five as Mr. Universe, and one, as Mr. World. What was he?… Veg. or Non-Veg.? - Non-Veg.! The boxer Mohammed Ali… Cascius Clay… Non-Veg.! - Mike Tyson… Non-Veg.! Yes of course, Non-Veg. food does add to the strength… that is a scientific fact. That is the reason that if you analyze, that when a person is convalesing from a disease, it is preferable… Non-Veg. food - Not that you have to have Non-Veg., it is preferable… egg, etc.- I will come to it later on. And then they give an example of a wrestler… Professor Ram Murthy - Never heard his name. He says he is a world famous wrestler - Who has heard of him?. Any one has heard of him?… Prof. Ram Murthy? No one - World famous… Where did he get this news from?… World famous. Then he gave the example of Paramjit Singh in London… pure Vegetarian, who skips 2000 times a day - therefore vegetarian food makes you an athlete. If these are the arguments… supposed to be scientific, I really feel ashamed. Most of the athletic record holders… here is the Guinness Book… you can go through it - I have brought it along here… all mentioned, about body building… body building, athletic, hundred metres dash. All these people, if at random also you check up their, dietetic history - Even giving benefit of doubt, more than 80 to 90 % will be Non-Veg. But I will be a fanatic, if I say that all these records are only due to the diets… I will be a fanatic - A few records may be related to the diet, but not all. Further argument that he gave, that… ‘The smell and the sight of a Carnivorous animal is strong, the night vision is strong’ - As Mr. Rashmibhai Zaveri said… ‘Night vision and sense of smell is strong in Carnivorous… in Herbivorous, it is less… in human beings it is less, therefore we should be Vegetarian. There are Herbivorous animals like the ‘Bee’ whose sense of smell is very strong, and they even have a very good night vision. See, these arguments, which are not scientific, may be useful in a debate to convince the people illogically - Therefore I am here. Then he gave the example… ‘You know animals have hoarse voice… you know, coarse voice - the Carnivorous animals - Herbivorous animals do not have coarse voice.’ I want to ask you a simple question - Which animal is maximum known for a hoarse voice? - Donkey! Veg. or Non-Veg.? Veg. or Non-Veg.? Veg.! Anyway, by no means am I trying to prove that Vegetarian food creates hoarse voice, or Non-Vegetarian food creates melodious voice. If you see the list of singers, many are Non-Veg.… many are Veg. also. So just by quoting singers who are Vegetarian - ‘Oh! that is why Vegetarian diet makes you melodious’... is all illogical arguments - Really I feel ashamed to answer all these things. And he gave certain ‘Economic’ points… that is economic reason, why we should have Vegetarian food - It is more economical, according to Mr. Zaveri. And he gave several statistics - so many calories, so many this, so many tons of protein, which are mentioned here - From where they get this statistics, God alone knows. And he mentioned some protein… it is also mentioned in this book, that 1 kg. of animal protein that we get, we have to feed so many plants, etc., therefore it is equivalent to 7 kgs. of Veg. protein. So if you are having meat… for 1 kg. protein, you are taking 7 kg. vegetables - therefore vegetable is cheaper. How they get this kg. of proteins, - I being a medical doctor do not realize - Is it kg. of food, or kg. of protein? And if agree with him... I agree with him - you say for sake of argument, 2 + 2 is 5,.. I agree - and I ask you that you take 2 rupees... take 2 rupees, and give me 5 rupees - take 2000, take 2000, give me 5000. Similarly, If I agree it is right… all their statistics, then I tell, that the Vegetarians, they should thank the Non-Vegetarians. You know why?… because if we would not have slaughtered the animals for food, it would have lived for another five to ten years, and in that time it would have the vegetables of 7 to 8 peoples for a few years. So you should thank us for preventing the animals from eating your vegetable food. Further more, he gave the calculation from some record… from where I do not know, 1:14 the land that you graze, required for animal, is 14 times more than the land required for food, etc. Same example is given here, that the land required to produce one ton of beef - the same land you can feed 5 average families. One ton of beef is equivalent to 10 or 20 tons of Veg. food, and the land required to graze an animal, can raise 5 average families. My earlier argument also holds good here - But besides that, these ideological Vegetarians… they fail to realize that the animals graze on land which is unsuitable for growing crops. They eat the plants which is inedible for the human beings… like husk and stocks… corn stocks. They do not eat plants which are edible for the human being - Yes! they can eat… But when they enter the fields, the farmer, but natural, takes them out of the field - Why to cause loss? Yes, if we have excess of crop, etc., there are certain governments who even feed them. And there are Nomadic populations who make their living, by grazing animals on land which is unsuitable for crop growing - But they eat the vegetation which is inedible to the human being and they make their living - Even the animal lives, even the human being lives. And today according to U.N report, about 23% approximately, of the land in the world is used for pastures, 23% for forest, less than 10% for cultivation, the remaining 45% majority can yet be used for growing crops. Why don’t you use that?… Why you are running after the food of the animals?… Poor living creatures… let them live, let them eat - Why you are stopping them from eating? If the Non-Vegetarians stop slaughtering the cattle, do you know that, there will be over population of cattle… over population. I am aware that human beings… they raise animals for food - that means, by methods, they increase the multiplication of the animals. But if suppose I agree that from today, all Non-Vegetarians stop raising animals for food, and stop killing them for food, yet they will grow in population. You know why?… Human beings… in all these years our population is increasing, even with all the family planning method, with all the birth control… ‘Hum do Humare do’ - Yet we are increasing. There is no birth control method among the cattle, and their gestation is less than the human beings, 5 months to 6 months to 8 months - Less then the human beings and they multiply faster. So if we stop killing and stop raising… yet, within a few decades, we will have problems… not of over population of human beings - of over population of cattle - How you are going to solve it? There are various Nutrition… he talked about ‘Protein’, etc. - if time permits I will speak in the rebuttal. I would like to make a statement of Dr. George R. Kar, which is sufficient to counter all his arguments on health. Dr. George. R. Kar, he is the professor of Nutrition, in the University of Texas. Why I am giving the designation, you can come to know that these people actually specialize in catching health fraud - People who deal in, fraud in health. He says that… ‘Virtually all authors of The diet and Disease books - they propose hypothesis which are untested, ill-tested, unfound, unlikely or disproved’. I would like to repeat - Dr. George R. Kar says… ‘Virtually all authors of books on diet and disease - they propose hypothesis which is ill-tested, unfound, non tested, unlikely or disproved’. Time is running short. I would like to make the statement that is given by ‘The American Council on Science and Health’ - Just a statement…. See they are experts. These quotations of research are not scientific facts… all these quotations… that this causes diseases, that… Some are scientific facts, but they can be prevented, but the others things what is mentioning about this land and that land… these are only statistics done by individual researchers. Even when you do Phd. - you can do a research that will come into account, but will not carry weight. American Council on Science and Health says that... ‘A person need not abstain from meat, and be a Vegetarian to have a healthy diet’. And the topic is not... ‘Veg. or Non-Veg. which is healthier?’ - It is… ‘Is Non-Veg. food, permitted or prohibited for the human beings?’ And I will list out the points in summary, to make it easier for Mr. Zaveri to answer, in the rebuttal. Point No. 1 - There is not a single major Religion, which bans or prohibits all
Non-Veg. food in general. Point No. 2 - Geographical places like Arctic, where Eskimos live - how could you have provided food all these years back, and today also if you provide, it is going to be more expensive. Point No. 3 - If all life is sacred, why do you kill the plants… even they have life. Point No. 4 - Even plants feel pain. Point No. 5 - Even if I agree that they have two senses less - killing a creature of two senses less, is a lesser crime… is illogical. Point No. 6 - It is preferable to kill one animal and take one animal life, than to take 100 lives of plants, for feeding 100 people. Point No. 7 - Each and every argument can be disproved… the liver and the kidney, HCL, same with saliva, same with the Ph. of the blood, same with the Lipoprotein. Point No. 8 - The human beings have an Omnivorous set of teeth, for eating Veg. as well as Non-Veg. Point No. 9 - They have a digestive system which can digest both Veg. and Non-Veg., and I have proved it scientifically… I have proved by the enzymes. Point No. 10 - Primitive man was Non-Veg. - So you cannot say... ‘It is prohibited for human beings’ - human beings... means, it is even for that person. Point No. 11 - The food you eat has an effect on you behavior - but saying that ...
‘Non-Veg food makes you violent’, has got no scientific base at all. Point No. 12 - Giving arguments that...‘Veg. food makes you strong, makes you peaceful, makes you intelligent makes you athletes’, are all myths. Point No. 13 - ‘Night vision and sense of smell, is strong in Carnivorous - in Herbivorous it is less’. ‘The Carnivorous animal has hoarse voice, you know coarse voice - Herbivorous animals do not have coarse voice’... are all illogical arguments. Point No. 14 - ‘That Veg. food is cheaper’… I have disproved it - It is not economical. In certain countries - Yes! like India, it can be - But if you go abroad, in the Western countries, Veg. food is more expensive - And fresh Veg. food is phenomenal… Fresh vegetables. Further more…. Point No. 15 - That... ‘the land required to graze the animal, will cause scarcity of the land for growing crops’... is also wrong. Point No. 16 - If the Non-Vegetarians stop slaughtering the cattle… do you know, that there will be over population of cattle. Point No. 17 - According to Dr. Kar… ‘These books written by dietitians, they cannot be relied upon’. All these statistics given, are mainly from there. Point No. 18 -There is not a single statement in any authentic medical book which says... ‘Non-Veg. food in general, should be banned’. Point No. 19 - There is not a single government on the face of the earth, which has banned all Non-Veg. food, as a general rule. And, Point No. 20 - that even ‘ The American Council on Science and Health’ has said that...‘For a healthy diet, being a pure Vegetarian is not required’. These are sufficient proofs, logical and scientific, that Non-Veg. food has to be permitted. If Mr. Zaveri does not agree, I request him to answer scientifically - not by comparison on just ‘Researches’. But yet, if Mr. Rashmibhai Zaveri does not reply to more than 20 points which I have put forth, yet I will not ask him to become a Non-Veg. - because I am not a fanatic Non-Vegetarian… I am not. Yet if he wants to continue eating vegetarian food, I have got no objection - It is a personal choice… It is a personal choice. Some people like… due to certain taste, etc. - it is a personal choice. And, only thing I would like to tell the people that… the Vegetarians, the ideological Vegetarians who do so much propaganda that... ‘This has got more value, etc.’ - they should stop such things, and stop distributing these type of books, which mislead the people. I would like to end my talk by given a quotation from the Glorious Qur’an, from Surah Nahl, Chapter 16, Verse 125, which says... (Arabic)… That is… ‘Invite all to the ways of thy Lord with wisdom and beautiful preaching, and argue with them, and reason with them in the ways that are best and most gracious’. Wa Aakhiru Dawana Anil Hamdullillahi Rabbil Aalameen.
(Clapping)
(Dr. Mohammed) I now call upon Mr. Rashmibhai Zaveri, to present his response to Dr. Zakir Naik - Ladies and gentlemen, Mr. Rashmibhai Zaveri.
(Clapping)
(Mr. Zaveri) First of all, I really thank Dr. Zakir Naik for giving me the choice, whether I would like to still remain a Vegetarian or Non-Vegetarian - Thank you very much. I would request Mr. Coordinator, that would you like to have the rebuttal or my comments now - or shall we have… because after all you know, this is a…
(Dr. Mohammed) Now it is better you know… we will…
(Mr. Zaveri) Let us have some Question-Answer if you think.
(Dr. Mohammed) Question-Answer… we will have in the third session - We have three-part session - Yes, Mr. Zaveri you can continue.
(Mr. Zaveri) Any how, we are totally at the command of the co-ordinator, so I will obey.
(Dr. Mohammed) No... as decided you know… the same format we will keep.
(Mr. Zaveri) I will obey.
(Dr. Mohammed) I will not allow Dr. Zakir also, to change the format… I will object.
(Mr. Zaveri) Now, first thing that I will say… it is not the question of whether one is logical or illogical, and it is not a question of the choice that one makes - as I said is my talk earlier, everything is relative, and you have to understand this topic from that perspective. Now one thing that I will very strongly object with respect to Dr. Zakir’s… ‘that not a single Religion prohibits Non-Veg’. I am expert… I can say because I am a student, I have done M.A. in Jainology - I can say from my Religious point of view, that Lord Mahavir and our all 24 Tirtankaras, very vehemently prohibited Non-Veg. food - I have already given you some quotations. You see, mainly arguments of Dr. Dean Ornish is based on the fact, that Non-Veg. food contains excessive protein, cholesterol, and saturated fat. So that is why he said that… ‘For healthy and peaceful living, you must have Non-Veg. diet… No… Veg. diet’. Now, he said that plant has also got life - No, it is not only proved by Dr. Jagdish Chandra Bose, but even our Lord Mahavir - he stated 2500 years ago, that… ‘Not only plants… air, water, fire, minerals of the earth, they all have life. He has not said that you are allowed to kill this life, and maintain yourself - but he was a practical Tirtankara - so he said, that those who cannot renounce this world and became Jain Muni. You know Jain Munis… they do not even kill plant vegetation or even other a living beings for their food - they beg the food, which is cooked in our house. We will not go into that controversy… ‘That even you kill it, and then, give them’… that is a separate story - but the teachings of Mahavir are very clear, that you shall not harm any living being, whether animate or inanimate. Now, because of certain constraint, for those people who cannot renounce the world, he has said that at least you can avoid essential killing. He has said that… ‘Even if you… when you have food made out of plant, it is violence, it is Hinsa… but it is necessary - So what I prohibit is, unnecessary killing’. Friends, this is a very sharp distinction, but very important distinction we should make - that if the alternative is available, we should not go for that alternative, which compels us to kill and eat our own fellow creatures. Another thing he said… ‘plants’… In my talk I stated about… ‘plant food’, and he said that… ‘Even a Lizard can grow tail’ - that is the only exception. The plants, you pluck fruits… they will give you make fruits - you cut their branches… more branches will grow. See there is no end to such argument… so let us restrict our argument to this. About medical science… and he has rightly stated that… medically also, he has given certain things - I have also stated. Now it is for the enlightened audience to decide, whether the scientific facts that I have given are correct, or he has given - it is okay… it is a question of argument. Now he has conveniently forgotten - Please excuse me… I am telling because I am trying to rebute your thing - It is a psychological aspect… When we consume animal food, we also inherit certain animal instincts. What have you to say? - Please, in your rebuttal you can say that. Now, doctors also… most of the doctors prescribe raw vegetable - Now coming to cooking, most of the doctors prescribe raw vegetables, for healthy diet. Only that food or cereals, which will not be proper for a human being to consume raw… that only can be cooked. But as far as possible… and in our ‘Indian Vegetarian Congress’, we always, whenever we have a meeting, we have most of the food raw… uncooked, and that is more healthy, according to us. About the books… these books were not given by me to Dr. Naik, and it was given by my friend Mr. Salecha, who approached me - that is okay… it is nothing very important. Now I will tell you one thing, that you cannot alter the truth, by just loud applause. Okay, if you are impressed by my argument, you can applause me, or if you are impressed by the other argument, you can applause that. But I firmly believe, that just because some arguments are appealing to you, and you applause them loudly, will not alter the truth. And I will… I have referred to about one book… one Dr. Deepak Chopra, he has also written many books - he is also a physician… practicing physician, like Dr. Dean Ornish. He has also conducted researches, and he has come out with a theory, that your food will have terrific effect an your impulses and urges, your physical development, psychological development and emotional development. You know, most of the psychological and emotional distortions, are because of the flesh food that one eats, and that is why it is prohibited. It is totally illogical to say… ‘That by eating animals, you are helping Vegetarians’. We should not worry about the animal population, because nature is quite capable of taking care. Why?… Because we are… because we are rearing more animals, animals for killing - that is why, then if we are not doing it… look at the jungle… everywhere the natural cycle is there, balancing will take care of itself nobody has to worry about it. Now as per the history that Mr. Trivedi also referred, and also Dr. Zakir - now I will tell from Jain historical point of view, that in our Jain scriptures, it is mentioned very clearly that the people… those persons who were living in prehistoric stage, they lived under a tree, and they were sufficiently provided by trees - they did not have to go for any killings. Friends, I am of course given more time, but I am… I really personally feel that let us not have a sort of a dialogue or arguments between… I would like very much, the audience to participate and have more time for Question-Answer… thank you.
(Clapping)
(Dr. Mohammed) Thank you Mr. Zaveri - We have 5 minutes more… he has taken 5 minutes less. Now, I call upon Dr. Zakir Naik, to present his response to Mr. Rashmibhai Zaveri… for 15 minutes only.
(Clapping)
(Dr. Zakir) Alhamdullillah Was Salaatu Was Salaam Ala Rasullillah Wa Aala Aalihi Was Sahabihi Ajmayeen - Ama Bad. Auzbilla Himanesh Shaitan Ir Rajim, Bismillah Hir Rehmaanir Raheem.
(Arabic)…
Respected people on the dais, and my respected elders, and my dear brothers and sisters, I welcome once again all of you with the Islamic greetings ‘As Salaam Alaikum Wa Rahmatullahi Wa Barakatuhu’ - May Peace, Mercy, and Blessings of Allah Subhanahu Wa Taala, be on all of you. I have not conveniently forgotten anything. If you realize, I spoke may be a half minute more than the time allotted - so how can he say... ‘ I conveniently forgot?’ If you give me even five hours more, if you are willing to stay… because you are the person who kept time restrictions… you know less time… Thirty. I had to bargain for fifty minutes - I would love to speak for two hours… even full day. I can do it, because I am a marathon speaker… Alhamdulillah… I am a Non-Vegetarian.
(Clapping)
Mr. Zaveri said that... ‘I said that... No Religion prohibits Non-Veg’. I never said… ‘No Religion’ - I said ‘No major Religion’ - it is being recorded… ‘No major Religion’ - and Jainism is not a major Religion, according to the books you gave me. You gave certain books - Jains are only 0.4% of India - 0.4 - less than 1 percent - Can you call it a major religion? - In India - leave aside the world - World out of the question - negligible - I am very clear cut in my statement. Regarding the argument on Jainism I can reply, but the coordinator will not give me permission… I am restricted to Islam - you know I can reply even on Jainism… I am a student of comparative Religion.
(Dr. Mohammed) Excuse me sir, you cannot interfere when the speaker is speaking.
(Dr. Zakir) Brother is saying... ‘I did not say’ - you can very well see the Video cassette... ‘There is not a single major Religion which bans or prohibits, all Non-Veg. food in general’ - You can see the Video cassette.
(Dr. Mohammed) You can ask the question… in question time.
(Dr. Zakir) Do not get irritated… the diet will help you… do not get irritated. Brother Rashmibhai Zaveri said… ‘I did not answer, whether you get animal instinct’. I said in my lecture, I think you did not hear - I said... ‘We eat peaceful animals like goat, sheep, because we want to be peaceful’ - and therefore when I came… starting, I always said... ‘Peace be on all of you’. Further, he said I did not state… ‘Dr. Dean Ornish’. I yet challenge him - if his book is referred by any authentic Medical College - authentic book… not just dietary books - that answer I already gave… by Dr. Willam T. Jarves… ‘Even scientists and medical professionals are not immune to the ideological thinking of the Vegetarians - They are not immune’. It is not a medical book… he may have written a diet book. I am very clear in my words… I do not mix words. And Dean Ornish, whatever his name is… may be very famous - I do not know him… I am hearing for the first time… I do not know - I yet ask him to prove and check, whether that book is referred, as a text book, not as a medical book… a text medical book, in a college - that shows the authenticity. He said…‘We should not worry about the cattle... nature will take care’ - It is you all who are so much worrying… we are not worrying. Nature made them in such a way, that the moment you kill them, they will again come - God is the Creator… Allah made them. If we kill Lion, Tiger, they will become extinct… therefore we cannot have their food. The cattle, we can have… God has made them that way - If we do not follow the instruction of God, they will be overpopulated. And regarding cutting of plants, what he said... you know people say that... ‘ If we have plants, the mother is yet alive’ - So in that way the offspring of the Cow, of the Goat, the Calves - that means… can we eat them? Yes! Because mother is yet alive… the Cow is yet alive, and when the offspring becomes a mother, we can also kill the mother. So even if I agree with his logic… ‘The plants survives’- in the animals, more lives are surviving than the plants - if I agree with his logic. Further more I said that… ‘Best is, prevention is better than cure’. I agree with Dr. Ornish when he says that… ‘You know, vegetarian diet is helpful for certain disease’ - Even I advice that - Where did I say… ‘No’? But the topic is not… ‘Which food is healthier?’ - but making a statement… ‘It is, banned for human beings’. I challenge any authentic medical book… I am a doctor… not books… whether given by Rushabh Foundation or Indian Vegetarian Congress - Whatever it is… these books are stating things which are unfound, ill tested, unproved. There is a Islamic method of ‘Prevention is better than cure’ which will answer most of your questions - The Islamic method is there of ‘Prevention is better than cure’. When we slaughter the animal, we do the ‘Zabihah’ - we cut the throat, and the wind pipe, and the vessels of the neck, without damaging the spinal cord - otherwise the nerve going to the heart may get severed… there will be cardiac arrest. When the spinal cord is not damaged and the vessels of the neck are slit open, along with the throat and the wind pipe, the heart is pumping… most of the blood flows out of the body. Blood is a very good media of germ and bacteria. If you slaughter the animal in this way, most of the diseases transmitted by blood, many which you named, can be eliminated, can be prevented - the meat remains fresh for a longer time. If it is slaughtered in the Islamic method - and people say... ‘Oh! It is a merciless … you know you all are so mercilessly killing … it dies of pain’.When we slaughter in the Islamic method, when we cut the blood vessels of the neck, the blood supply going to the nerves which is responsible for pain, is severed - So the animal does not feel pain. The animal kicks and withers … you know why? - Due to the gush of flow. The animal does not feel pain - it is contracting and relaxing, because there is lack of blood in that part of the body. The animal does not die of pain … it dies a painless death - painless… painless. We eliminate most of the disease transmitted by blood. Secondly, there are many countries in the world, and many people, who raise animals… they give them hormones. And one was mentioned, by Mr. Zaveri… he did not name - It is called as ‘DES’ Diacecerol Beseserol. It is a hormone injected to cattle, so that they become fat, and you get more money for flesh - This is ‘Haram’... in Islam. ‘Carcinogenic hormones’… if injected animals - even if you slaughter by the ‘Zabihah’ method, it is yet ‘Haram’ It is ‘Zabihah’, but not ‘Halal’... It is ‘Zabihah’ , and ‘Haram’. If the cattle are injected with hormones... you are not allowed to have those hormones, neither are we allowed to have Cows, which are fed with Non-Veg. - because the Prophet said... ‘Any animal that is fed with Non-Veg., it is prohibited for you’. After that, if you take care of hygienic conditions, and cook the meat very well, most of the diseases which Mr. Zaveri spoke of… not all - Most of them will be eliminated. And in the Non-Veg. flesh food… the most dangerous, which is commonly eaten, is pork. It has more than 70 different diseases which you can get, if you inject pork… more than 70 different diseases - and one of them is ‘Ischemic heart disease’ which he spoke about. Because pork has more of fat building material than muscle building materials - It gets deposited on the walls of the vessels causing Artheresclerosis, Hyper tension, etc. That is the reason in the Qur’an, no less than four different places in Surah Baqrah, Chapter No. 2, Verse No. 173, in Surah Maidah, Chapter No. 5, Verse No. 3, in Surah Anam, Chapter No. 6, Verse No. 145 and Surah Nahl, Chapter No. 16, Verse No. 115, it says…(Arabic)… ‘Forbidden for you for food are dead meat, blood, the flesh of swine, and any food on which, any name besides God’s name has been invoked’. It is ‘Haram’ - So we abstain from it, and we prevent several diseases of Non-Veg. Qur’an says in Surah Taha, Chapter No. 20, Verse No. 81… ‘Eat of the food We have provided for you in sustenance, but commit no excesses there in’. Most of the diseases what Mr. Rashmibhai Zaveri spoke about, is due to excessive eating. Even if you eat excessive Veg. food, you will have many diseases - I will not say do not have Veg. food… I am a doctor, I am not an ideological, neither a fanatic Non-Vegetarian. So if you prevent eating in excess, most of the diseases will be prevented. If you follow the Islamic guidelines, slaughter in the Islamic method, remove the blood, do not give hormones, cook the food very well, hygienic conditions, avoid pork, do not eat in excess, most of the diseases can be prevented - It answers most of his arguments. Few are yet remaining - if time permits, during Question-Answer time if you ask, I will reply. Do you know, they are talking about healthy food… healthy food… talking about all research and experiments - I will talk something which is a fact. According to Dr. William… again very famous person - Dr. William, he says that... ‘Vegetarian food extends the life of a human being, for more than six years’. If you have Veg. food, as compared to Non-Veg. food, you will live six years longer - Again hypothesis... hypothesis. If you analyze, a data was collected about all the people who lived above 100 years from 1932 to 1952, and on this data a person by the name of Osegares - he wrote a book ‘Living to be Hundred’ - 1200 people who did… and why they did it - Everything is mentioned… In it even diet is mentioned. Do you know out of 1200 people, how many were Vegetarian? - How many, guess… 1000 - Four! Four!… Four! This survey was not done to prove Veg. food or Non-Veg food - It was done for other reasons… but even the diet was mentioned. It is a fact… It is not a research - It is a fact. Out of 1200 people who lived in a span of 20 years, over 100 years… only four were Vegetarian. You know ‘Alcohol’? - Alcohol alone - It is a Veg. diet, or no? ‘Alcohol’ is Veg. or Non-Veg?… Veg! - From juices of fruits. And the disease that are caused by alcohol alone, is more than all the Non-Veg., diseases put together - One vegetable diet! So just for alcohol, I cannot say that all vegetable food should be banned. Today scientists… and even he will agree… it is mentioned in his book also - the cause of maximum deaths today is… ‘Alcohol’… number one - So I do not ban all Veg. food. What do I say? - As Qur’an says in Surah Maidah, Chapter No. 5, Verse No. 90 … (Arabic)… That… ‘O! ye who believe, verily intoxicants and gambling and idol worship and dedication of stones and divination of arrows - these are Satan’s handiwork - Abstain from it, that ye may prosper’. ‘Alcohol’ is a Satan’s handiwork… abstain from it. I have only prohibited ‘alcohol’… not all Veg. food. And smoking… Second greatest cause of death in the world - Veg. or Non-Veg.? - Veg.! Can you prevent the alcoholic disease? - Only when you can prevent is, when it is defermented - it ceases to be Alcohol. Can you prevent smoking disease? - Do not have tobacco… Only option is prohibition. If there is no prevention, then comes the question of prohibition - So alcohol is prohibited. There are more than 400 Fatwas by Islamic scholars - ‘Smoking is prohibited’ because there is no prevention. You know Kesri dal... Kesri dal - Indian government has banned it. It causes ‘Spastic Paraplegia’... staple food of North West, Indians! Banned, why? - It causes death also… ‘Spastic Paraplegia’. ‘Alcohol’ - Many countries have banned… including Saudi Arabia, including states in India have banned it. Smoking in Singapore is banned in public places, in government places, in public transport. ‘Kesri dal’- banned by India. If there is no prevention, then you can ban it. I do not know of a single government, that has banned all Non-Veg. food in general… Not a single. Yes! few Non-Veg. food like pork - Saudi Arabia has banned. There is no prevention… ban it! - If there is no prevention, then you prohibit it. And the debate was not... ‘Which is better, which is healthier - Veg. or Non-Veg.?’ The debate was ... ‘Is Non-Veg. food permitted or prohibited?’ I gave a list of more than 20 points - So I can very well say that Mr. Rashmibai Zaveri conveniently stopped his talk five minutes before, not to answer these things - If you give me one hour more, I will continue speaking. Wild berries… they are poisonous, Stitch beans… vegetable food - they are poisonous, Datura… poisonous. What is the solution? - Do not have it. You know ‘Water’ - Water has so many diseases transmitted… Cholera, Paratyphoid, Typhoid, it causes Amebiaces, Giadiasis, Round worm, Pin worm, Wild Hepetises - I can go on talking… only by water. What do you do… Do you ban water? - You prevent it… You purify the water… the diseases will be prevented. You know ‘milk’ - Milk has so many diseases… Chizelia, Cholera, Paratyphoid, Typhoid, Tuberculosis, Salmonelesis, Brusolosis - I can go on listing. What do you do?… Do you ban milk?… What do you do? - You pasteurize it… You do not ban it… You do not prohibit it - It is un-medical. Whether milk is Non-Veg. or Veg. … is a debatable topic - I will not argue on that. So if you cannot prevent the disease, then do you prohibit it? I have given various reasons, which Mr. Rashmibhai Zaveri has not replied. There is not a single government, who has banned Non-Veg. food in general, there is not a single major Religion which has banned Non-Veg. food in general - therefore I say that... ‘Non-Veg. food is permitted - not prohibited’. If I have hurt the feelings of any Vegetarian, while giving the replies to the speaker, I sincerely apologize from the bottom of my heart. I would like to end the talk, by giving the quotation of the Glorious Qur’an, from Surah Isra, Ch. No. 17, Verse No. 81, which says…(Arabic)… ‘When truth is hurled against falsehood, falsehood perishes, for falsehood is by its nature bound to perish’. Wa Akhiru Dawana Anil Hamdulillahi Rabbil Aalameen.
(Dr. Mohammed) I now call upon Mr. Rashmibhai Zaveri to present his response to Dr. Zakir Naik -Ladies and gentlemen, Mr. Rashmibhai Zaveri.
(Clapping )
(Mr. Zaveri) First of all, I really thank Dr. Zakir Naik for giving me the choice whether I would like to still remain a Vegetarian or Non-Vegetarian - Thank you very much. I would request Mr. Coordinator that would you like to have the rebuttal or my comments now, or shall we have… because after all you know this is a…
(Dr. Mohammed) Now it is better you know we will….
(Mr. Zaveri) Let us have some question answer if you think.
(Dr. Mohammed) Question-Answer… we will have in the third session… We have three-part session - Yes, Mr. Zaveri you can continue.
(Mr. Zaveri) Any how, we are totally at the command of the coordinator, so I will obey.
(Dr. Mohammed) No… as decided you know… the same format we will keep.
(Mr. Zaveri) I will obey.
(Dr. Mohammed) I will not allow Dr. Zakir also to change the format… I will object.
(Mr. Zaveri) Now, first thing that I will say - its not a question of whether one is logical or illogical, and its not a question of the choice that one makes - as I said is my talk earlier, everything is relative, and you have to understand this topic from that perspective. Now one thing that I will very strongly object with respect to Dr. Zakir’s… ‘That not a single religion prohibits Non-Veg.’... I am expert… I can say because I am a student, I have done M.A. in Jainiology - I can say from my Religious point of view, that Lord Mahavir and our all 24 Tirtankaras, very vehemently prohibited Non-Veg. food - I have already given you some quotations. You see, a mainly argument of Dr. Dean Ornish is based on the fact that Non-Veg. food contains excessive protein, cholesterol, and saturated fat.So that is why he said that for healthy and peaceful living, you must have Non-Veg. diet… No… Veg. diet. Now he said that plant has also got life – No, it not only proved by Dr. Jagdish Chandra Bose, but even our Lord Mahavir… he stated 2500 years ago, that not only plant, air, water, fire, minerals of the earth, they all have life. He has not said that you are allowed to kill this life and maintain yourself - but he was a practical Tirtankara… so he said that those who cannot renounce this world and became Jain Muni. You know Jain Munis they do not even kill plant Vegetation, or even other living beings for their food - they beg the food, which is cooked in our house. We will not go into that controversy… that even you kill it, and then give them - that is a separate story… but the teachings of Mahavir are very clear… that you shall not harm any living being whether animate or inanimate.Now because of certain constraint, for those people who cannot renounce the world, he has said that at least you can avoid essential killing. He has said that even if you… when you have food made out of plant it is violence, it is ‘Hinsa’ - but it is necessary… so what I prohibit is unnecessary killing. Friends, this a very sharp distinction, but very important distinction we should make… that if the alternative is available, we should not go for that alternative which compels us to kill and eat our own fellow creatures. Another thing he said ‘Plants’… in my talk I stated about plant food, and he said that ‘Even a lizard can grow a tail’ - that is the only exception.The plants… you pluck fruits - they will give you more fruits, you cut their branches … more branches will grow. See… there is no end to such argument… so let us restrict our argument to this. About medical science… and he has rightly stated that medically also, he has given certain things - I have also stated. Now it is for the enlightened audience to decide whether the scientific facts that I have given are correct, or he has given - it is okay… it is a question of argument. Now he has conveniently forgotten - please excuse me… I am telling because, I am trying to rebut your thing - the psychological aspect… when we consume animal food, we also inherit certain animal instincts.What have your to say? - Please in your rebuttal you can say that.Now, doctors also, most of the doctors prescribe raw Vegetable - Now coming to cooking most of the doctors prescribe raw Vegetables, for healthy diet.Only that food or cereals which will not be proper for a human being to consume raw… that only can be cooked. But as far as possible and in our Indian Vegetarian Congress, we always, whenever we have a meeting, we have most of the food raw, uncooked and that is more healthy, according to us. About the books, these books were not given by me to Dr. Naik, and it was given by my friend Mr. Salecha, who approached me - that is okay… it is nothing very important.Now I will tell you one thing… that you cannot alter the truth by just loud applause. Okay, if you are impressed by my argument, you may applause me, or if you are impressed by the other argument, you can applause that.But I firmly believe, that just because some arguments are appealing to you and you applause them loudly, will not alter the truth.And I will… I have referred to about one book - One Dr. Deepak Chopra… he has also written many books - he is also a physician, practicing physician like Dr. Dean Ornish. He has also conducted researches, and he has come out with a theory that your food will have a terrific effect an your impulses and urges, your physical development, psychological development, and emotional development.You know most of the psychological and emotional distortions, are because of the flesh food that one eats, and that is why it is prohibited.It is totally illogical to say that by eating animals, you are helping Vegetarians.
We should not worry about the animal population, because nature is quite capable of taking care. Why? Because we are… because we are rearing more animals, animals for killing -that is why, then if we are not doing it, look at the jungle - Everywhere the natural cycle is there, balancing will take care of itself… nobody has to worry about it. Now as per the history that Mr. Trivedi also referred, and also Dr. Zakir - Now I will tell from Jain historical point of view, that is our Jain scriptures - It is mentioned very clearly that the people… those persons who were living in prehistoric stage, they lived under a tree and they were sufficiently provided by trees - they did not have to go for any killings.Friends, I am of course given more time, but I am, I really personally feel that lets not have a sort of a dialogue or arguments between…I would like very much the audience to participate and have more time for question answer - thank you.
(Clapping)
(Dr. Mohammed) Thank you Mr. Zaveri - We have 5 minutes more… he has taken 5 minutes less.Now, I call upon Dr. Zakir Naik to present a response to Mr. Rashmibhai Zaveri… for 15 minutes only.
(Dr. Zakir) ‘Alhamdullillah Was Salaatu Was Salaam Ala Rasullillah Wa Aala Aalihi Was Sahabihi Ajmayeen – Ama Bad’. Auzbilla Himanesh Shaitan Ir Rajim, Bismillah Hir Rehmaan Nir Raheem.
(Arabic….) Respected people on the dais, and my respected elders and my dear brothers and sisters, I welcome once again all of you with the Islamic greetings… ‘As Salaam Alaikum Wa Rahmatullahi Wa Barakatuhu’ – May Peace, Mercy and Blessings of Allah Subhanahu Wa Taala be on all of you. I have not conveniently forgotten anything. If you realize, I spoke may be a half minute more than the time allotted - so how can he say… ‘I conveniently forgot?’ If you give me even five hours more, if you are willing to stay - because you are the person who kept time restrictions… you know less time… Thirty. I had to bargain for fifty minutes - I would love to speak for two hours - even full day.I can do it, because I am a marathon speaker… Alhamdullilah - I am a Non-Vegetarian.
(Clapping )
Mr. Zaveri said, that I said that ‘No religion prohibits Non-Veg.’. I never said… ‘No Religion’ - I said… ‘No major Religion’ - It is being recorded… ‘No major Religion’… and Jainism is not a major Religion, according to the books you gave me. You gave certain books - Jains are only 0.4% of India - 0.4 , less than 1 percent - Can you call it a major Religion in India? - leave aside the world - World out of the question… Negligible - I am very clear cut in my statement.Regarding the argument on Jainism… I can reply but the coordinator won’t give me permission… I am restricted to Islam - you know I can reply even on Jainism… I am a student of comparative Religion.
(Dr. Mohammed) Excuse me sir - you cannot interfere when the speaker is speaking.
(Dr. Zakir) Brother is saying… ‘I did not say’ - you can very well see the Video cassette… ‘There is not a single major religion which bans or prohibits, all Non-Veg. food in general’ - You can see the Video cassette.
(Dr. Mohammed) You can ask the question, in question time.
(Dr. Zakir) Do not get irritated… the diet will help you… do not get irritated.
Brother Rashmibhai Zaveri said I did not answer - whether you get animal instinct.
I said in my lecture, I think you did not hear - I said… ‘We eat peaceful animals like Goat, Sheep, because we want to be peaceful’… and therefore when I came, starting I always said… ‘Peace be on all of you’.Further, he said I did not state ‘Dr. Dean Ornish’. I yet challenge him… if his book is referred by any authentic medical college, authentic book - not just dietary books… that answer I already gave… by Dr. Willam T. Jarves – ‘Even scientists and medical professionals are not immune to the ideological thinking of the Vegetarians’ - They are not immune. It is not a medical book… he may have written a diet book. I am very clear in my words - I do not mix words.And Dean Ornish, whatever his name is… may be very famous… I do not know him … I am hearing for the first time… I do not know - I yet ask him to prove and check whether that book is referred, as a text book… not as a medical book… a text medical book, in a college - that shows the authenticity. He said… ‘We should not worry about the cattle - Nature will take care’ - It is you’ll who are so much worrying - we are not worrying. Nature made them in such a way that the moment you kill them, they will again come - God is the Creator - Allah made them.If we kill Lion, Tiger, they will become extinct… therefore we cannot have their food. The cattle… we can have - God has made them that way - If we don’t follow the instruction of God, they will be over populated. And regarding cutting of plants, what he said… ‘You know people say that if we have plants, the mother is yet alive’ - So in that way the offspring of the Cow, of the Goat, the Calves… that means can we eat them?Yes! Because mother is yet alive… the Cow is yet alive, and when the offspring becomes a mother, we can also kill the mother.So even if I agree with his logic… ‘The plants survives’ - in the animals, more lives are surviving than the plants - if I agree with his logic.Further more I said that best is, ‘Prevention is better than cure’. I agree with Dr. Ornish when he says that you know Vegetarian diet is helpful for certain disease - Even I advice that… where did I say no?But the topic is not, ‘Which food is healthier?’ - But making a statement… ‘It is, banned for human beings’. I challenge any authentic medical book… I am a doctor… not books - whether given by Rushabh Foundation or Indian Vegetarian Congress - whatever it is… these books are stating things which are unfound, ill tested, unproved.There is a Islamic method of ‘Prevention is better than cure’, which will answer most of your questions - The Islamic method is there of ‘Prevention is better than cure’.
When we slaughter the animal, we do the ‘Zabihah’ - we cut the throat, and the wind pipe, and the vessels of the neck, without damaging the spinal cord - otherwise the nerve going to the heart may get severed - there will be cardiac arrest. When the spinal cord is not damaged and the vessels of the neck are slit open along with the throat and the wind pipe, the heart is pumping - most of the blood flows out of the body. Blood is a very good media of germ and bacteria. If you slaughter the animal in this way, most of the diseases transmitted by blood, many which you named, can be eliminated, can be prevented - the meat remains fresh for a longer time. If it is slaughtered in the Islamic method… and people say… ‘Oh! It is merciless … you know you all are so mercilessly killing… it dies of pain’. When we slaughter in the Islamic method, when we cut the blood vessels of the neck, the blood supply going to the nerves which is responsible for pain is severed - So the animal does not feel pain. The animal kicks and withers… you know why? Due to the gush of flow.The animal does not feel pain - it is contracting and relaxing because there is lack of blood in that part of the body. The animal does not die of pain - it dies a painless death… painless, painless. We eliminate most of the disease transmitted by blood. Secondly there are many countries in the world and many people who raise animals, they give them hormones.And one was mentioned, by Mr. Zaveri - he did not name - it is called as ‘DES’ Diacecerol Beseserol.It is a hormone injected to cattle so that they become fat, and you get more money for flesh - This is haram in Islam. ‘Carcinogenic hormones’ - if injected animals, even if you slaughter by the ‘Zabihah’ method, it is yet haram. It is ‘Zabihah’, but not halal… It is ‘Zabihah’, and haram.If the cattle are injected with hormones you are not allowed to have those hormones, neither are we allowed to have Cows, which are fed with Non-Veg. - because the Prophet said… ‘Any animal that is fed with Non-Veg.... it is prohibited for you’.
After that - if you take care of hygienic conditions, and cook the meat very well, most of the diseases which Mr. Zaveri spoke off, not all - Most of them will be eliminated.
And in the Non-Veg... flesh food… the most dangerous, which is commonly eaten, is pork. It has more than 70 different diseases which you can get, if you inject pork - more than 70 different diseases - and one of them is ‘Ischemic heart disease’ which he spoke about. Because pork has more of fat building material than muscle building materials - It gets deposited on the walls of the vessels causing Arthrocerouis, hyper tension, etc. That is the reason in the Qur’an, no less than four different places in Surah Baqrah, Chapter No. 2, Verse No. 173, in Surah Maidah, Chapter No. 5, Verse No. 3, in Surah Anam, Chapter No. 6, Verse No. 145 and Surah Nahl, Chapter No. 16, Verse No. 115, it says…(Arabic…) ‘Forbidden for you for food are dead meat, blood, the flesh of swine, and any food on which, any name besides God’s name has been invoked’. It is haram - So we abstain from it, and we prevent several diseases of Non-Veg. Quran says in Surah Taha, Chapter No. 20, Verse No. 81, ‘Eat of the food We have provided for you in sustenance, but commit no excesses there in’.Most of the diseases what Mr. Rashmibhai Zaveri spoke about is due to excessive eating. Even if you eat excessive Veg. food, you will have many diseases - I will not say… not have Veg. food - I am a doctor, I am not an ideological, neither a fanatic Non-Vegetarian. So if you prevent eating in excess, most of the diseases will be prevented. If you follow the Islamic guidelines, slaughter in the Islamic method, remove the blood, do not give hormones, cook the food very well, hygienic conditions, avoid pork, do not eat in excess, most of the diseases can be prevented - It answers most of his arguments. Few are yet remaining - if time permits during question answer time if you ask, I will reply. Do you know, they are talking about healthy food - healthy food - talking about all research and experiments - I will talk something which is a fact. According to Dr. William - Again very famous person… Dr. William, he says that… ‘Vegetarian food extends the life of a human being for more than six years’. If you have Veg. food, as compared to Non-Veg. food, you will live six years longer - Again hypothesis… hypothesis. If you analyze, a data was collected about all the people who lived above 100 years from 1932 to 1952, and on this data a person by the name of Osegares - he wrote a book, ‘Living to be Hundred’ - 1200 people who did… and why they did it - Everything is mentioned in it… even diet is mentioned. Do you know out of 1200 people, how many were Vegetarian? - How many… guess? 1000… Four! Four! … Four.This survey was not done to prove Veg. food, or Non-Veg. food - It was done for other reasons… but even the diet was mentioned.It is a fact… It is not a research - It is a fact. Out of 1200 people who lived in a span of 20 years, over 100 years, only four were Vegetarian.You know alcohol? - Alcohol alone… it is a Veg. diet, or no? Alcohol is Veg. or Non-Veg.?… Veg! - from juices of fruits.And the disease that are caused by alcohol alone is more than all the Non-Veg. diseases put together - One Vegetable diet! So just for alcohol, I cannot say that all Vegetable food should be banned. Today scientists… and even he will agree… it is mentioned in his book also - the cause of maximum deaths today is, alcohol… Number one - So I do not ban all Veg. food. What do I say? - As Qur’an says in Surah Maidah, Chapter No. 5, Verse No. 90…(Arabic…) That… ‘O! ye who believe, verily intoxicants and gambling and idol worship and dedication of stones and divination of arrows - these are Satan’s handiwork - Abstain from it, that ye may prosper’.Alcohol is a Satan’s handiwork… abstain from it. I have only prohibited Alcohol - not all Veg. food.And smoking… Second greatest cause of death in the world - Veg. or Non-Veg.? – Veg.! Can you prevent the Alcoholic disease? - Only when you can prevent, is when it is deferment - it ceases to be Alcohol. Can you prevent smoking disease? - Do not have tobacco - Only option is prohibition.If there is no prevention, then comes the question of prohibition - So alcohol is prohibited. There are more than 400 Fatwas by Islamic Scholars – ‘Smoking is prohibited’ because there is no prevention. You know Kesri Dal, Kesri Dal - Indian Government has banned it.It causes ‘Spastic Paraplegia’ staple food of North West, Indians! Banned, why? - It causes death also – ‘Spastic Paraplegia’. Alcohol - Many countries have banned including Saudi Arabia, including states in India have banned it. Smoking in Singapore is banned in public places, in Government places, in public transport.Kesri Dal - banned by India. If there is no prevention, then you can ban it. I do not know of a single Government that has banned all Non-Veg. food in general - Not a single.Yes! few Non-Veg. food like pork - Saudi Arabia has banned. There is no prevention - ban it! - If there is no prevention then you prohibit it. And the debate was not, ‘Which is better, which is healthier – Veg. or Non-Veg.?’ The debate was – ‘ Is Non-Veg. food permitted or prohibited?’ I gave a list of more than 20 points - So I can very well say that Mr. Rashmibhai Zaveri conveniently stopped his talk five minutes before - not to answer these things - If you give me one hour more, I will continue speaking. Wild berries… they are poisonous, Stitch beans, Vegetables food… they are poisonous, Datura… poisonous. What is the solution?… Do not have it. You know ‘Water’ - Water has so many diseases transmitted - Cholera, Paratyphoid, Typhoid, it causes Amebiaces, Giadiasis, Round worm, Pin worm, Wild Hepetises - I can go on talking… only by water. What do you do? Do you ban water? - You prevent it… You purify the water… the diseases will be prevented. You know ‘Milk’ - Milk has so many diseases… Chizelia, Cholera, Paratyphoid, Typhoid, Tuberculosis, Salmonesis, Brusolosis - I can go on listing. What do you do? Do you ban Milk? What do you do? - You pasteurize it… You do not ban it… You do not prohibit it… It is un-medical. Whether milk is Non-Veg. or Veg. is a debatable topic - I won’t argue on that.
So if you cannot prevent the disease, then do you prohibit it? I have given various reasons, which Mr. Rashmibhai Zaveri has not replied. There is not a single Government who has banned Non-Veg. food in general - There is not a single major Religion which has banned Non-Veg. food in general… therefore I say that Non-Veg. food is permitted - not prohibited. If I have hurt the feelings of any Vegetarian, while giving the replies to the speaker, I sincerely apologize from the bottom of my heart.I would like to end the talk by giving the quotation of the Glorious Qur’an, from Surah Isra, Chapter no. 17, Verse No. 81, which says... (Arabic)… ‘When truth is hurled against falsehood, falsehood perishes, for falsehood is by its nature bound to perish’. Wa Akhirm Dawana Anil Hamdulillahi Rabbil Aalameen.
(Clapping )
(Dr. Mohammed) Now, we begin the open question and answer Session.
To extract maximum benefit in the limited time that we have available in the Question and Answer Session, we expect the following rules to be observed - Your Question should be on the topic only: that Is ‘Is Non-Vegetarian Food Permitted Or Prohibited For A Human Being?’ - Questions out of the topic will not be permitted. Kindly state your question briefly and to the point - this is not a lecture time, neither a cross question time for the questioners. I repeat, kindly state your question briefly and to the point - this is not a lecture time neither a counter question time for the questioners. Mr. Zaveri and Dr. Zakir should answer comprehensively and each answer should not exceed five minutes. Four mikes have been provided in the auditorium - two next to the stage for the Gents and two in the rear central isle for the ladies. If you wish to put a question to Mr. Zaveri, kindly queue up behind the mike with the name clip… ‘Question for Mr. Zaveri’ - Similarly so in the ladies. And if you wish to put a question to Dr. Zakir, kindly queue up behind the mike with the name clip.. ‘Question for Dr. Zakir’. Only one question at a time may be asked -for your second question, you would have to go right at the back of the queue again and avail your second chance. Written questions on slip papers which are available from the volunteers in the aisles would be given secondary preference if time permits. On your slip where you are putting your question, kindly tick or write to whom your question is addressed - ‘Mr. Zaveri’ or ‘Dr. Zakir’ or it might be put aside.
Kindly state your name and profession before putting forward your question, so that the speakers would be in a better position to answer you. We would allow one question on each of the mikes in a clockwise rotation, alternately addressed to each speaker.May we have the first question from the mike on my left so we have first gents, ladies, two… then gents. Yes brother we can have the first question from you.That is for Mr. Zaveri?
(Q). Ya… yes, respected Chief guest and Mr. Zaveri, my question is, you have spoken Non-Vegetarian is prohibited from various angles.And you have spoken about your Lord Mahavir… Mahavir advised that killing animals and living happy at the expenses of others is prohibited. Now please explain to me… did Mahavir say that can you eat Vegetarian? - Vegetarian in the sense, I mean… Mahavir never go and cut trees and have Vegetable foods - He was always sitting under the tree and the food which he has eaten is mostly fruits which has fallen from the tree - He was not plucking up the fruits and ate. So please explain to me… because you have spoken on the subject of this ‘Vegetarian, Non-Vegetarian is prohibited’ for that thing… and please explain to me what is the Jain view - because your idea, your idea is the what Mahavir says… what Mahavir says.
(Mr.Zaveri) Please, I have understood your question… I will reply.See… what Lord I have stated already that what Lord Mahavir stated, that even plant has got life, and he says that even eating vegetable food is… as per the Jain scriptures is prohibited for Jain Muni. But because of constraint, everybody cannot become a Jain Muni… that is why he said that at least the unnecessary killing of animals should be avoided.He never said that eating of plant food is allowed even for Jain Munis.
(Dr. Mohammed) Yes sister, question for Dr. Zakir.
(Q). As Salaam Alaikum brother Zakir - I am Humaima here… I have a question. There are various pamphlets distributed by a Vegetarian society quoting the Qur’an from Surah Haj, that… ‘It is not the meat nor the blood that reaches Allah but your piety that reaches him’. Thus proving, that Islam prohibits killing of animals for food - There are many quotations from Qur’an and Hadith, showing concern for animals.
(Dr.Zakir). I would like to thank this sister. She has asked a very fundamental question, that there are certain pamphlets distributed by organizations… proving from the Qur’an and Hadith, that Non-Veg. food… a Muslim should not have, it is prohibited - and this was the initiation of this debate. I did not touch on it because, you know they told me to keep out of Religion - but since it is a question, I am compelled to answer.This was the pamphlet, that the President of Rushab Foundation, Mr. Dhanraj Salecha, he gave - and how this debate was initiated - He gave this pamphlet quoting from the Qur’an. I will just give also reference - the reference is a bit wrong out there- but I do not catch on to the reference - he is quoting a verse from Surah Haj, Chapter No. 22, Verse No. 37, which says… ‘That it is not their meat, nor their blood which reaches Allah, which reaches God, but it is your piety that reaches him’. And I agree with that, totally - it is indicating that Islam is not like certain other Religions which believe that Almighty God requires blood and meat to survive. It is saying that when you sacrifice, blood does not reach God, meat does not reach God - It is your intention, it is the righteous, it is the piety with which you sacrifice… Allah considers that piety. That is the reason, when we sacrifice in Idd-ul-Zuha, minimum 1/3rd portion of that animal has to be given compulsory to the poor people, 1/3rd can be given to friends and relatives, and maximum 1/3rd you can keep for personal use. There is no part kept for Almighty God. Because Qur’an says in Surah Anam, Chapter 6, Verse 14, that… ‘He feedeth everyone but does not require to be fed’. Allah… Almighty God feeds everyone - He does not require to be fed. This verse is clear, that when you sacrifice, Allah sees your intention - He does not require blood and meat of the animal. There is one more quotation… Here are various… it will take me one hour to reply to all - I will just pick the second quotation of the Qur’an - there are two Qur’anic quotations. It says in Surah Baqrah Chapter 2, Verse 20, that… ‘When they turn away, they create mischief through the land, by destroying crops and cattle - Allah loves not those who make mischief ’. After giving this quotation… below it is mentioned, that… ‘therefore you should not have Non-Veg.’- their interpretation. The Arabic word used is ‘Nasl’ which some have translated as ‘Cattle’ - It actually means ‘Progeny’. But irrespective whether ‘Nasl’ you translate as –‘Cattle’ or ‘Progeny’- If you read the context –‘Those people who create mischief throughout the world, by destroying crops and cattle or progeny - Not slaughtering for food… destroying for creating mischief - Allah does not like those who make mischief ’. So if you kill any animal, even the plant if you kill, for making mischief, Allah does not like. If you say this verse refers to ‘not having for food’ - that means you should not even… even the crops. If I agree with you this verse refers not to have ‘cattle’ - even ‘crops’ is there.It is a very wrong way of argument… they do not do self analysis –‘Crop’ is also mentioned there. If they say by this Verse… ‘Non-Veg. is prohibited’, even Veg. is prohibited. It is not… neither Non-Veg. is prohibited, neither Veg. is prohibited.Certain food which Allah has prohibited is mentioned in the Qur’an - the others Allah says in Surah Baqrah, Chapter 2, Verse 168, ‘Eat of the good food We have provided for you’. Regarding animal’s concern… yes there are various Hadith - if you read Sahih Bukari, Volume No. 3, Hadith No. 551, and Sahih Bukarai, Volume No. 8, Hadith No. 38… It speaks about a man who gave water to a thirsty dog, and Prophet said, ‘He will be rewarded’. So people asked, ‘Do you even have reward for giving water to a thirsty dog?’ The Prophet said… ‘Yes! For every kind act you do to the animal you will be rewarded’.Imagine in the days of ignorance… ‘Yaumil Jahiliyah’ - fourteen hundred years ago, where human beings were treated like animals - our beloved Prophet Muhammad Sal Allahm Alaihi Was Sallam spoke about animal rights. Prophet said, ‘Do not overload the animals’. You know today in India two Bullocks are supposed to carry by law not more than 500 kgs. - They carry more than a ton. Prophet said… ‘Do not overload them, do not ill treat them, do not tie them and shoot them’. Mentioned in Sahih Muslim, Volume No. 3, Hadith No. 4812. - It is also mentioned in Sahih Al Bukhari – ‘Do not tie the animals and shoot them’. It is mentioned in Sahih Muslim, Volume No. 3, Hadith No. 4810, that… ‘When you slaughter the animal, see to it that the knife is sharp, so that the animal does not feel pain. Do not slaughter one animal in front of the other - Do not kill the animal twice’. He said you know that… ‘Adrenahive is released’ - It releases in the blood… the blood goes out of the body.Prophet spoke of ‘Animal concern’ - We should protect their rights, but for food if it is a lawful animal, you can have it - Hope that answers the question.
(Dr. Mohammed) Yes sister…
(Q). It is mentioned in the book ‘100 facts about Egg’ on Page No. 8 and 9, Fact No. 13… ‘Ethiopians are of the view - if a pregnant woman eats Egg, her child would be born bald headed and would be deficient in reproduction’. It is also mentioned in Fact No. 18… ‘Some African countries believe that if a child is given to eat Egg before teething, he may become mentally retarded’.Are these scientific facts or are these suppositions? If you say these are Scientific facts, then could you please prove it authentically… and if you say it is superstitious, then why are you promoting falsehood by such books that is… ‘Hundred facts about Eggs? ’… Thank you.
(Mr. Zaveri) Thank you sister one thing I have not written that book… second thing I have not given that book to you, and I have not referred to anything from that book. So it is not necessary to answer… particularly for that book… but I can definitely say which I have already touched upon in my subject… because Egg contains excessive Protein and Cholesterol and saturated fat - that is why it is not healthy for any human being, and particularly for pregnant women and children.
(Dr. Mohammed) Yes the next question from the mike on the right.
(Q). I am Fazal Sarang… by profession I am a architect - My question is to Dr. Zakir Naik. ‘Is the Non-Veg., Non-Vegetarian food, is the only reason for the heart disease?’
(Dr. Zakir) The brother has asked a very good question that… ‘Is Non-Veg. the only reason for the heart disease’. And this was spoken by Mr. Zaveri that… ‘Flesh… animal flesh, Chicken, Mutton, Beef, causes heart disease’- It can cause… He is right. And he further said… ‘There is not a single Vegetable source which contains Cholesterol’ - If you tell that to any doctor, not the ideological Vegetarian - they will agree.Heart disease is caused when the diet contains more Fat, and more Cholesterol, irrespective whether it is Veg. or Non-Veg… Irrespective.Non-Veg. food do contain high Cholesterol, but even Vegetable food - Groundnut oil, Cashew nut, Coconut, ghee, butter… all this.Even a common housewife knows - You know why? There are Ads. in the media - ‘Have Safola oil - will not cause heart disease’ - indicating the other oils cause heart disease. Simple… you do not have to be a doctor – it is a blatant, 100% falsehood.I being a medical doctor, I challenge… I challenge Mr. Rashmibhai Zaveri to answer… ‘Does butter contain fat or not ?’ And the doctors do tell the people suffering from heart disease - ‘Do not have fat, do not have butter, do not have Groundnut oil, do not have Cashewnut oil’… from where did he get this idea from? - From these books. This book he gave to me… Correct? - this book you gave to my brother - Who gave it? Mr. Salecha… Mr. Salecha gave this book. In this book also it is mentioned the same thing… that there is no Cholesterol in Vegetables. I am sorry if I thought… because it is the first time I am meeting Mr. Zaveri here - If he did not give these books, I apologize.But… but, one thing that all these books are published by Jain organizations - You know… and distributed in Bombay - Cheap… cheap - I am not blaming.
(Mr. Zaveri) Please… Please.
(Dr. Zakir) I do not want to hurt anyone’s feeling.
(Mr. Zaveri) Let us not have a dialogue across the this thing.
(Dr. Zakir) …. I am… I am… I am not going to hurt anyone’s feeling - I am sorry I did not want to say that - but I was compelled. I do not want… If it is not, you say it is not written by Jain - It is not written.
(Mr. Zaveri) No… you said Dr. Zakir that I should reply.
(Dr. Mohammed) Excuse me…
(Dr. Zakir) You will have a… you will have a chance in the question answer time.
(Dr. Mohammed) Sir… sir I will let you allow you time - you know in your time you can respond back. No… I will allow you to respond back - anything you want… in your time.
(Dr. Zakir) I would request the Chairman to give me half minute more… I was disturbed - half minute more.
(Dr. Mohammed) No… No, he is too smart - We will not give him half minute more.
(Dr. Zakir) See because so many allegations… ‘Egg’… he told, ‘Egg is the cause’ - Egg does contain… Egg does contain Cholesterol - It is rich in Cholesterol, but it is not the major cause. Today’s research and medical books also say that… that the Cholesterol in the Egg is not the major villain, it is the saturated fat in which you fry the Egg… butter, ghee, Lard, Pork, which is the main villain . If you do not have these frying in ghee, butter, there are less chances of having Eschimic heart disease, by Egg. And today amongst the population, 2/3rd of the population are non responders to Cholesterol. The moment there is high intake of Cholesterol, like taking Egg… the liver immediately cuts its own production - and the level that reaches the blood is the same.There are 1/3rd people who are responders to Cholesterol, they have a problem - they should abstain from yoke of the Egg. Otherwise even if you have one - two Eggs a day, you will not have heart disease. And if you have it with bacon, with pork, then the problem - If you fry in ghee you will have a problem - If you fry in Groundnut oil, you will have a problem. Causing baldness - I do not want to give example… I do not want to give example – Even if you check here, there are many people who are bald - there are great philosophers who were bald… I do not want to take their names… I do not want to hurt your feelings. So this thing is just a research which is based on illogical assumptions - A research should be practical.And the associate factors for heart disease is also alcohol as well as smoking - These two are also one of the associate causes for heart diseases. Yes! In America heart diseases are more in Non-Veg. because they have fat. Qur’an says… ‘Do not have in excess’, this problem will be solved. Secondly, the Vegetarians of America - they are affluent. It is a vogue to be a Vegetarian, because you know… to buy Veg. food is expensive.
If you drive a Mercedes car, you they have status - If you have Veg. food it is status, there. About 3 to 7 percent are Vegetarian in America - less than 1 percent are pure Vegetarian… less than one percent… because they are affluent and they are rich, they take more care of hygiene.And many Vegetarians ideologically also… like even Mr. Rashmibhai Zaveri may agree that Alcohol is prohibited, smoking is prohibited - because of associated factors, the case of heart disease in Vegetarian is less. But anyone who has food which is rich in cholesterol or fat… irrespective whether it is Veg. or Non-Veg., he will have heart disease.To prevent it, follow the guidance in the Qur’an in Surah Taha, Chapter No. 20, Verse No. 81, that… ‘Do not commit excesses’. That reminds me of a story - In School we had learnt, that there was a religious priest who ate excessive food and he had 64 ladoos, and when he came back, his wife said that… ‘Why don’t you have Churan Chutki?’… Some digestive. So he says… ‘Are bauli, akal na aay banke che bachaon ki maata, agar churan chutki ke liye jhagha hoti, tho main dho laddoo aur na bog leta’.
(Dr. Mohammed) Brother…
(Q). The question is directed to Mr. Rashmi Zaveri - this is a book I have come across which is named ‘Meat eating - 100 facts’... Please sir… this is not… concerning to you…
(Dr. Mohammed) You may put your question saying… ‘One book writes like that’ -Rather than saying… ‘this person’s book’ or that you say… ‘this book states so and so’- that would be acceptable.
(Question Contd…) Okay, here is a book from Jain publication - you being a Jain, I am asking you a question, which is… the name is… ‘Meat eating 100 facts’ written by Dr. Nameechand. And it gives a cartoonic representation of meat eating people, which I feel it is very insulting… and I mean it is degrading… I mean defaming.I just want to ask you - in this Jains being tolerant… tolerant - is it fair enough for Jains to publish such books which can hurt people’s feelings? I mean.. is this.. it is mockery, I mean - Please answer.
(Dr. Mohammed) Yes the speaker would not like to answer to that - I give him the full right not to answer to the question which a speaker feels is not suitable.
(Question Contd…) But I am just asking about…
(Dr. Mohammed) We will allow the second question…. We will… we will.. the speakers… Okay, the next question please for the… he… he passes… passes the answer - he would not like to respond.
(Question Contd…) I am not satisfied.
(Dr. Mohammed) See the speakers have a right… see the… I would request the questioners not to get worried or agitated in any sort. The speakers have a full right not to respond or if they feel your question is not right or not suitable for them, they have a right not to respond back - Kindly note. So put your question and frame it in such a way, that it is not vulgar, neither derogatory and… yes… so it should not be derogatory to the speaker, or to a particular faith - Put it is a factual manner… ‘This is what is stated - What is your opinion?’ Do not give your comment in a derogatory manner - Ask what do you say about this? Yes… do not give your opinion - Let the speaker give their opinion on the subject - Yes sister… the next question for Dr. Zakir… Dr. Zakir.
(Q). Salaam Wa Alaikum brother - my name is Azra. I would like to ask - in a book promoting Vegetarianism, by Gopinath Agarwal, on page 15 and 16, he says that… ‘The milk a Cow gives in its life time, can satisfy 90,000 persons at one time… but the same Cow is killed for flesh, can satisfy 1000 persons at one time - the same applies for Goat also. He says killing the Goose that lays a golden Egg… daily, is never a wise proposition- Do you agree with him?’
(Dr. Zakir) Sister has asked a question again from the same book, and I would like to make a clarification - Mr. Salecha he gave these books, and said that you can have more books - the letter is there if you want. And these books are available at various market places - people are bound to buy, etc. Therefore I am telling, I am requesting the people.
(Audience) How many times are you repeating this thing… So many times you are repeating… so many times.
(Dr. Zakir) That is right - the brother has asked… ‘Why am I repeating? ’ - Because all the arguments are mentioned here. These arguments, if it is not mentioned here, I would not have repeated it.
(Mr. Trivedi) Please… please I think your tempers must be calm - What Mr… Doctor… what Mr. Zaveri… what Mr. Zaveri said very correctly… ‘Book is written by somebody else - It should be… it is he who should try to defend the book’ - Mr. Zaveri does not want to defend the book… so let us forget the book, and ask all questions which are pertaining to the talk.
(Dr. Zakir) Correct! And I agree with it. I agree with it - Mr. Zaveri read from books… he did not do a research - he read books which are speaking against Non-Vegetarians. He read books, and he presented the facts - Either I accept it, or say the fact is wrong. I cannot say… ‘Because I did not write the book no one can ask me questions’ - that is illogical. If you ask me any question pertaining to Non-Veg. food, I either say the book is false… or I say that… ‘It is illogical, or it is logical’. Why do you have to get irritated? - It is a book promoting Vegetarianism. If someone gets me a book against Islam, I will say that book is false.
(Dr. Mohammed) Excuse me… I do not allow a debate between the audience and the speakers. The audience just put the questions… the speaker can only answer the question - Do not get involved. I will not allow Dr. Zakir, neither Mr. Zaveri to get involved in any debate with the audience - this is not a debate time for the audience… Kindly note - You can continue with the answer.
(Dr. Zakir) I am going to start with the answer… you can start the timing also.
If I am going to be interrupted every time - I want to give a complete answer.
I would request the chairperson not to be biased towards one person only - If they are interrupting my answers I have to be given time.And sister raised an argument which is there not only in this book, even in other books - on internet - You go to the internet, the same argument is given. First thing is that… Is Milk, Veg. or Non-Veg.?… is a big question - there are Vegetarians who say that Milk, is Non-Veg. This book… I am not blaming the speaker… this book again says… ‘Milk, is Non-Veg. ’ - if we have Milk… so many diseases. Other Vegetarian foundations say… ‘No… We are lacto Vegetarian… We have Milk’ - Whether Milk is Non-Veg. or Veg., my simple question is… ‘If you do not want to hurt the animal… when you Milk… when you Milk the animal, it causes severe pain - You know?’ Artificial milking of animal causes pain.You ask a breast feeding woman, certain times she has problems, and she has to extract Milk artificially, it is so painful - So when you extract Milk from the animals… it is painful. When you do not agree that animals are meant for food, how can you milk the animals? - The cattle and the Cow. It is so painful - It is nothing but robbing the animals. If you say the animal is not meant for food and if you have the Milk of that animal you are robbing the Milk which is meant for the offspring - For the Calves. And the example that was given, that a Cow on a average in a day, gives 10 kgs. of Milk - Again, this book if it is wrong, no problem… It is there on internet also… 10 kgs. of milk in a day, in a month 300 kgs., in a year about 3000 kg. Do you calculate Milk in kgs.?… In litres - Why in kgs., I do not know - Ask the author. And then further it says that 3000 kg. of Milk, if you feed 6000 people… so in full life time, it will feed 90,000 people at one time - And the Cow if you kill… only one 1000 people - Which is better, 90,000 or 1000? Why are you killing the Goose that is laying the golden Egg daily? It is not a wise proposition… And I agree with that.But the point to be noted is, that no Milk-man will ever give a milking Cow to the slaughter house. No slaughter house will ever purchase a milking Cow, because a milking Cow is multiple times more expensive than a Cow which has passed it’s age of milking. In Bombay, it costs 25 to 25,000 Rupees - milking Cow - An old Cow which has crossed the milking age cost only 3 to 5 thousand rupees. So.. what we do… we Non-Vegetarians… the cattle… we look after it till the time it gives milk - after it stops giving Milk, we slaughter it. We take all the Eggs of the Goose - When it stops laying, we slaughter the Goose for its flesh. Saap bhi mare aur lathi bhi na toothe! Two birds with one stone - We are more intelligent.Again the argument given… ‘that see some animals you can use them in fields, etc.’… you can use them for plugging, for transportation. If you love the animals so much, why do you overload them? And further more, the Indian statistic tells us that out of the population of cows, Ox and Bulls, only 25% are productive… the remaining 75% are unproductive - Either passed the age of milking, or they are males - All are not females… Bulls, Oxen. Now what will you do with this 75% of excess non-productive Cow, Goat, Bulls, Ox… one option, you rear them up yourselves. An average bull or Cow requires 18000 a year for living, according to the statistics. Their statistics… not my statistics - 18,000 a year.So after they give Milk, they live another 4 - 5 years - Which farmer will bear the burden of millions of Cow every year, 18000? Second option is give to Jivdaya organization - They leave it open it enters the field, eats up the crop. Third option - leave them in the jungle… animals will kill them. The last option is the best - after they reach the age of milking, utilize the Milk, give it to slaughter houses - it benefits the farmer, he gets the money, and even the animal benefits the human being - by eating the meat of the animal… as well as the hide for leather, as well as the bones - Hope that answer the question.
(Dr. Mohammed) Next question for Mr. Zaveri.
(Q). According to Kasturchand Jain… ‘In the marriage of the 22nd Tirthankar… Alasnemi popularly known as Neminath… meat of animals and birds was served, and both the bride and the bridegroom according to ‘Shastra’, were Jains’. Another incident was quoted that… ‘Chenya… a Jain Shravika, who was the wife of Bhimshan Shrenik, a contemporary of Mahavir… was pregnant, and she had the desire to eat the heart of her husband. Bhimshan’s eldest son Abhay Kumar, instead gave her some meat of a dead animal, and Cheniya, thinking it to be her husband’s heart, ate it’. I do not know how authentic is this article, and whether what Kastur Chand said, is true or false. What is it’s explanation… please explain - I am referring to the article from ‘The Caravan Series’, December 1981.
(Mr. Zaveri) Thank you sister - First of all, I will request the Coordinator to only allow those questions coming out of my talk - Not out of any other book or another references, for which I am not responsible. But because I am a true Jain, I know definitely about the Jain history - about Neminath Tirthankar. Yes it is true… that is why he propagated that the killing of - that is exactly why he renounced the world… ‘That for my marriage, are you going to sacrifice all these innocent creatures? No - I do not want such feast for me’… and that is why he became a Jain Muni and ultimately, a Tirthankar. So that is why I can say, that all Jain Tirthankaras have absolutely… on absolute terms, have prohibited Non-Veg. food. Thank you - and please restrict your questions to my talk only… not because it seems … I do not know… it seems that these books were given in all good faith… that they should understand our view point. It seems that they are all distributed to those people, and they are now asked… asked questions - I do not think that is fair. You can ask me any question from my talk… I will be very happy to say… I would like, and I could request…
(Dr. Mohammed) Any… any question can be asked on the topic… the thing is that whether it is in the talk, or out of the talk.
(Mr. Zaveri) I do not mind… that is okay.
(Dr. Mohammed) Er… not necessarily the book. Another point I will tell Mr. Co-ordinator, that Mr. Y.P. Trivedi and myself… we both have got other meetings, so we would like to conclude within five minutes.
(Dr. Mohammed) What I would suggest… see the time given to both the speakers to speak, was 50-50 minutes… then 15-15 minutes was for response, then we would have a Question-Answer session, for 50 minutes. If any of the speakers would like to forfeit the time of not carrying on with the Question-Session… if they have an emergency, I would excuse them, but I would continue the Question-Answer session for 50 minutes… because that has what been the chart given to me. I have to execute it… like I had been told Dr. Zakir cannot in his talk or response, speak or any other Religion… forcefully got him not to speak on it. I am telling you… forcefully I had to convince him… you cannot touch anything else – I got him convinced, because that was a request, he has respected. Now… now both… what both speakers have agreed to, I have followed that - anything which both speaker do not agree I have thrown it out. Let me be very clear… we had said 50 minutes… we will allow 50 minutes - but if one speaker would like to leave early, for any emergency or any requirement, a person has got a full free will and a choice - I would respect that requirement, but we will continue Question-Answer for 50 minutes. I have written down the time, 12:45 close down at around 01:30, right. So I think that is being very fair and clear on my part - The next question for Dr. Zakir.
(Q). As Salaam Alaikum Zakir bhai - my name is Khan Abdus Sami, and my question to you is… Food value charts are distributed by Vegetarians, showing that the proteins and iron content of Vegetarian food, is higher than Non-Veg. food… and thus they say Veg. food is more nutritious than Non-Veg. food - Your comments please… Thank you.
(Dr. Zakir) The brother has asked a very good question. I would like to reply to the question posed by the learned speaker also… he does not know who distributed them. It is given in writing out here… It is given by Rushabh Foundation, to IRF saying… ‘We would be pleased to give you more such material in huge quantities, if you like the same to be circulated among Muslim brothers in Mumbai’ - Free of charge… hah. The brother has asked a question… that there are fruit charts being distributed - yes even we get in our foundation. We did not respond, saying that it is… it is not worth responding… it is not worth responding. But when the request came from the Rushab Foundation… ‘Are you willing?’ I reluctantly agreed… ‘You know it is not a topic of scientific thing… it is a well known fact’. He said… ‘Yes we will debate’ - I said… ‘Fine’ - so I am here just replying - why should people get irritated? You can quote me from any book… as long as it is within the topic I will InshaAllah answer. If I do not know, I will say I do not know - if I know, I will say I know. I know your question… and even I have got that chart - it gives food value chart, saying that protein among the Veg. food is more than Non-Veg. food. And even Mr. Rashmibhai Zaveri in his talk, he said that… ‘Their value of protein… the quantity is more’. Mr. Rashmibhai Zaveri - he said that… ‘There were only three essential Amino acids’. You ask any doctor… it is not three… it is eight - No wonder five is lacking. It is eight essential Amino acids which are not synthesized in the body - the remaining are synthesized. These essential Amino acids should be given by the external food source. The protein of animal foods, they are biologically complete… known as higher proteins, because they contain all the eight essential Amino acids. The Veg. proteins are lacking in one or more of the essential Amino acids - It is a scientific answer. So even though the value may be more, 20 up, 10 down, it is not complete. The Veg. proteins are in complete protein, of lesser quality - Animal protein is of higher quality and complete protein. Similarly, if you analyze, even the Iron you get from the diet, is of two types - One is ‘Hem Iron’, one is ‘Non-Hem Iron’. ‘Hem Iron’ can be absorbed easily in the body - ‘Non-Hem Iron’ cannot be absorbed easily. In the animal food, there is ‘Hem Iron’ - as well as ‘Non-Hem Iron’. The Vegetable food contains very little ‘Hem Iron’… therefore they cannot absorb… therefore there is more deficiency of iron in them. So even I agree with you the Iron content in figures may be high, the protein content may be higher. Then the conclusion is… ‘Veg. food is more nutritive’ - It is misleading the people… It is nothing, but misleading. I would call it in plain English… ‘Fraud’. Who is doing it? - Some Vegetarian society… Misleading the people. And fraud is prohibited in every Religion… small or big - Whether major or minor Religion, fraud is prohibited. So I would like to ask you a question… ‘Would you prefer taking ten notes… ten notes of Rupees twenty, or one note of Rupees five hundred?’ If you know the value for money, you would choose the second - Hope that answers the question.
(Dr. Mohammed) The next question for Mr. Zaveri.
(Q) As Salaam Alaikum, I am Javed Shaikh - My question is to Rashmibhai. Rashmibhai… in your talk you mentioned, that diseases are transmitted through meat flesh, to human beings. But plants are also affected by some diseases… viral, bacterial diseases - So you can get diseases from plant… Vegetarian food also? You also mentioned Dean Ornish, and Deepak Chopra… references and recommendation of those doctors. If you believe in recommendations of doctors and medical professionals… Trivedi Sir also mentioned that. If you believe in that, I will quote only simple example. ‘When I was child… doctors… when I was suffering from fever… doctors were suggesting that do not take bath by cold water - But nowadays they are telling… when I gets fever… they are telling that… ‘Please take bath by cold water ah… ’ So if you are believing in quotations, statistical data, and medical things… So please give statistical data - Dr. Zakir Naik mentioned survey of America… regarding coronary heart disease. So do you have any statistical data regarding coronary heart disease in India - whether it is affected to… more susceptible to those who are having diet… Vegetarian diet or to Non-Vegetarian diet?
(Dr. Mohammed) I would request you all to put your questions briefly please.
(Mr. Zaveri) Your question is so long that one forgets.
(Questioner) Last part is the question.
(Dr. Mohammed) ‘Coronary heart disease’… he has asked.
(Mr. Zaveri) See… regarding coronary heart disease… Yes, plants also… if you consume the decayed plant… plant food I mean - the decayed fruits… definitely it will create germs. The point here is, that the animals that carry the germs… they are more dangerous, and they are likely to carry more diseases, than plant. Another thing is that, which I have said is, that the animal food contains excessive protein, cholesterol and saturated fat - So these two things combined… that will make… er... Non-Veg. food prohibitive. Coming to the statistics - I have got that book… there is no time… this is not a platform to argue about the statistics. I have got complete statistics - that more people are suffering because of heart disease… those who are flesh eaters, than the Veg. people. Now at the moment, I cannot give you those facts and figures - that… I have got it… then I can supply it to you later - Thank you.
(Dr. Mohammed) No counter question please - Yes, the next question for Dr. Zakir.
(Q) As Salaam Walaikum brother. Bother, my name is Safiya - I am a revert to Islam. My question is… in the book ‘Vegetarian or Non-Vegetarian - Choose for yourself ’ - by Gopinath Agarwal… there are quotations given from major world Religions including Hinduism and Christianity… that Non-Vegetarian is forbidden, prohibited –and how do you say it is permitted?
(Dr. Zakir) The sister is asking the question, that there are quotations from the same book, quoting various major world Religions like Christianity and Hinduism, saying that… in that religion, it is prohibited. So how come I have said that… ‘There is not a single major Religion, which says that Non-Veg. food in general, is prohibited?’ I clarified the Islamic view point - It is a misquotation… Out of context… Misunderstanding. I do agree one thing… that there are certain quotations… some times Non-Veg. food is prohibited, even in Islam. Like for example, the Verse I quoted Surah Maidah, Ch. No. 5, Verse No. 1, which says, that… ‘Do not do hunting in pilgrimage’ - within the sacred pilgrimage, do not do hunting. If you are fasting in the month of Ramzaan… Sunrise to Sunset… ‘Do not have Non-Veg. food - do not even have Veg. food’. If I say… ‘Do not have Non-Veg. food during fasting’ - that does not mean Non-Veg. food is prohibited - Prohibited only during that time. So similarly there are quotations in Religious scriptures… ‘At certain time in fasting… do not have Non-Veg. food’. Regarding your question in Christianity… and I have read that book, therefore I can reply - they say that in the Bible it is mentioned that… ‘You can not have dead food’. In brackets they put… ‘Meat’ - It is not there. What they are quoting… the reference is not given - I being a student of comparative Religion, I give talks on diets also. And they are referring to the book of Leviticus, Ch. No. 17, Verse No. 15, as well as the book of Deuteronomy, Ch. No. 14, Verse No. 21, it says that… ‘Thou shall not have the meat that dieth of itself ’. Dead meat is prohibited - Not all meat… dead meat. They say… ‘dead food’… and in bracket ‘meat’. It is… ‘dead meat is prohibited’. Even in the Quran, Surah Baqrah, Ch. 2, Verse 173, Surah Maidah, Ch. 5, Verse No. 3, Surah Anam, Ch. 6, Verse No. 145, Surah Nahl, Ch. 16, Verse No. 115… (Arabic)… ‘Forbidden for you for food are, dead meat, blood, the flesh of swine and any food on which any name, besides Allah has been invoked’. Where it is allowed ? If you read, the book of Genesis, Ch. No. 9, Verse No. 2 and 3, it says that… ‘They will fear you, they will dread you - all creatures of the earth, all fouls in the sky, all creatures that liveth on the earth, as well as all the fishes in the sea, they shall be delivered to you’. Next Verse Genesis, Ch. 9, Verse 3 says that… ‘Every creature that moveth on land, and is a living creature - they are meat unto you, and also herbs and shrubs’. Mentioned in the book of Deuteronomy, Ch. No. 14, Verse No. 9, that… ‘Ye shall have the meat of all the things in the water - All that have fins and scales, you shall eat’ - Deuteronomy, Ch. No. 14, Verse No. 11, says that… ‘You shall have the lawful meat of the birds’. Deuteronomy Ch. No. 14, Verse No. 20 says that… ‘Ye shall eat the meat of the lawful fowls’ - It is allowed. Further if you read, it is mentioned in the book of Hebrews, Ch. No. 5, Verse No. 13 and 14 that… ‘If you have Milk, you are weak - if you have strong meat, you are powerful in reasoning’ - Bible says that… not I. In the Gospel of Luke, Ch. No. 24… only quotations Verse No. 41 to 43… Jesus Christ (peace be upon him), goes in the upper room and he says… ‘Have you any meat to eat?’- And the disciples gave him a piece of broiled fish and honey comb… fish - and he ate before them. Jesus Christ (peace be upon him) - in the book of Romans, Ch. No. 14, Verse No. 2 and 3, it says that… ‘One who believth in eating all things, he can eat - those who are weak, they only eat herbs and shrubs - but anyone who eateth, should not insult those who eateth not - and those who eateth not, should not judge those who eateth - This is law of God’. Hindu scriptures - if you read the law of Manu, Ch. No. 5, Verse No. 30, it is clearly mentioned that… ‘The eater can eat any creature that lives - even if he eats everyday - our Creator created come creatures to eat, and some to be eaten’. Laws of Manu - Manusmriti, Ch. No. 5, Verse No. 31, it says that… ‘If you eat in a sacrifice… this is a law of a God’. Mamusmriti, Ch. No. 5, Verse No. 42, it says that… ‘A twice born…’
(Dr. Mohammed) Brother... Brother… now… please… please... Please…
(Dr. Zakir) I am always prepared… I am always prepared when I quote Scriptures -therefore it is not on the table… it is inside. I was not supposed to quote, unless compelled otherwise - Now they are compelling me to answer. Therefore I kept it behind - Otherwise my books are in the front always - they are compelling me to reply, therefore I am replying - It is within the rules of the debate. I have not completed yet - I have to speak for five minutes.
(Dr. Mohammed ) We would request anyone, not to disturb in between.
(Dr. Zakir) Please do not disturb - who is disturbing see… when I am speaking. We will have another 20 seconds… you know because this wastes time… you know, and then my time is up I will stop the speaker.
(Dr. Zakir) No… but if someone disturbs me, I should get more time.
(Dr. Mohammed) Acha… Okay we give... complete the answer in 30 seconds.
(Dr. Zakir) It is further mentioned in the Manusmriti, Ch. No. 5, Verse No. 35… ‘You can have meat’. In Rigved, Book No. 10, Hymn No. 16, Verse No. 10… ‘You can have meat’ - Rigved, Book No. 10, Hymn No. 85, Verse No. 13 - Rigved, Book No. 10, Hymn No. 86, Verse No. 13, says the same thing - You can have meat. In Mahabharat - Anushashan Parva, Ch. 88, if you read Bhisma gives the advice to Hridhistar. It is also mentioned in Manusmriti, Ch. No. 3, Verse No. 266 to 272 - It is mentioned there that… ‘If you want to please your ancestors, if you give herbs and shrubs, you will gratify them only for one month - If you give fish, for two months - If you give ‘Venison’ the flesh of deer, for three months - if you give mutton, for four months - If you give flesh of birds for five months, - if you give Goat meat for six months - if you give spotted Deer, for seven months - if you give meat of black Antelope for eight months - if you give Cow, one full year - if you give Bull it is twelve years, and if you give Rhinoceros and red meat of Goat, for ever… Inexhaustible. So if you have to satisfy your ancestor, according to Rigved, you have to give more… you have to give red meat.
(Clapping)
(Q). As Salaam Walaikum, my name is Gulfam and this question goes to
Mr. Zaveri. Sir, in your dialogue you said… ‘Jain Munis do not kill plants - they ask for alms’. So is it that they force others to kill plants for them… or is it that when they put masks on their face, they are not killing the germs, and others are killing the germs, by not putting the mask on their face? … What is it? … Please clarify.
(Dr. Zakir) It is a very good question sister - I am really very happy. Of all the questions… I would definitively give you first number, because it is said in Jain religion that… ‘You should not kill any body, you should not allow anybody to kill, and you should not appreciate if one kills’ - So all these three things are there. So if a Jain Muni comes to know that this food is prepared for him, he will not take it. So, this is the rule of Jain Muni. When… when they come to us for begging, they ask us very clearly - We also know that they will ask us… ‘Have you prepared anything for us?’ - We have to very honestly say… ‘We have not prepared anything - It is for us’. We have prepared say… four chapatis - He will take only one, we will be happy with three. This is the way of begging of a Jain Muni - He will not kill, he will not allow others to kill, he will not propagate killing. He will not even eat if he comes to know that this food is prepared for a Jain Muni. I am happy, that in this august and enlightened audience, I have been given an opportunity to clear the view points of ‘Jain Muni’ - thank you very much. And I will now request Coordinator that Mr. Trivedi and myself - It is really going on so nicely, that we would like to continue here for hours together… but I am sorry… that time constraint is such.
(Dr. Mohammed ) Last two questions, we will allow… five minutes are left.
(Mr. Zaveri) I do not think it will be…
(Mr. Trivedi) I think we have been talking so much about Vegetarian food and Non-Vegetarian food, that we are all hungry now. I think we should go and eat - so only last two questions and then we will leave.
(Dr. Mohammed) As Mr. Trivedi has said… ‘We will allow last two questions on the mike’ - Can we have the next question for Dr. Zakir.
(Dr. Mohammed ) Yes… Acha, there is a request for Mr… for you… want to ask question to.. no.. but you should have to follow... but I think you should have come.. come up in the queue you know .. ha…
(Q). Salaam Walaikum … Salaam Walaikum. My question for Zakir bhai is .. Are Non-Vegetarian food deficient?
(Dr. Mohammed) Acha, there is a request from the other speakers - what we will do… what I will do… see but there is a request from this side, ke allow one or two people to ask questions to Dr. Zakir. What I would suggest… let the speakers in the time they are available here… let the other two speakers ask questions… then Mr. Trivedi and Mr. Zaveri can leave - Then I will give the chance… so that I am not unfair to you also… both people. So that… no I have told them they wanted to leave… so I have to give them an opportunity to leave. They wanted those two people to ask questions… they can ask Dr. Zakir. Which are the two people Mr. Zaveri?… Mr. Bade, and .. Aaap do no ko chance de dengue ek. Then after that, we will carry on with - the other two people will be given chance so that I am not unfair to them, I hope the audience bears with me, for another ten… Mr. Trivedi and Mr. Zaveri would like to leave after that - So let those two people ask questions - Acha, we will allow only.
(Audience) No, no, no, Sir he is leaving - let us ask two questions to him, and let him go.
(Dr. Mohammed) Let those two people ask questions which Mr. Zaveri has requested - Mr. Bade… who is Bade?… Acha, one Mr. Bade, and that… Acha, and the other two… they two.. Acha, we will allow them to ask two questions.
(Q) To Dr. Hussain.
(Dr. Mohammed) Excuse me Mr. Zaveri… Acha, Okay… now one question for… one question he will ask - one you will ask - then I will allow Mr. Zaveri, after you will have finished your two questions… and one, one minute.
(Audience) Dr. Sahab…
(Dr. Mohammed) After they have finished their two questions - you have finished… you two - I will allow them to leave. Then the other two, who have missed their chance will be given permission. Beyond that, those who are missing because of these two people, will be given a chance… beyond that I will not allow, please. We have to complete the programme - Yes sir.
(Q). Dr. Sahab, Namaste… As Salaam Walaikum.
(Dr. Mohammed) Brief and to the point.
(Q) Dr. Saheb, Dr. Saheb…
(Dr. Mohammed) Brief Kishori… Sir… Brief and to the point.
(Q) My question is this - I went to see a picture ‘Khane Khuda’ - There were session of three days. People.. Haji Saheb jo the, they were wearing sandal wood - And then besides that, not eating any Non-Veg. food… No hair cut… nothing - Complete ‘Brammachari and Sanyasi’. When the picture was over, I asked them… ‘Bhai...what is this? Those three days complete renunciation - Sanyasi Bramachari?’… What reply they gave - he said… ‘Khane - Khuda tha’. Mein ne Kaha… ‘Musalmaan bhaiyoon, saara sansaar khane khuda nahin hain? Who hi khane khuda hai? – Zara teen deen aur rakte’.
(Dr. Mohammed) Bhai Saheb…. Apka question jara…. Bhai sabab.. Bhai sahab hamare chief guest ko aur hammare speaker ko jana hai - please could you forward your question.
(Q) ‘Saara sansaar khane khuda hai’ - please reply to me that wo… those three days they were offering, is ‘Khane Khuda’… what about the whole world is ‘Khane Khuda’- why the killing should not be stopped every where… especially in India, Mr. Naik?
(Dr. Mohammed) We will not allow that question. Sir, on the request of the chief guest and the speaker, we will not allow that answer, may we have the…
(Dr. Zakir) Mr. Rashmibhai Zaveri requested the person to ask a question out of turn, I am willing to answer… I am willing to answer. If chairman says no… chairman says no, then I will… I would love to answer, if you allow me.
(Dr. Zakir) Okay…Anyway, I will control the… nothing will go wrong.
(Dr. Mohammed) Okay, we will allow him… but a short… this thing… what… what was the question - I did not hear it?
(Dr. Zakir) I heard the question, I am supposed to answer.
(Clapping)…… It is a very good question.
(Dr. Mohammed) Okay… okay, now quickly and a quick answer, then we will allow the other gentle.. yes.
(Dr. Zakir) It is a very good question… It is a very good question - It will not create problems. I believe though you all are Vegetarians out here, we are not that violent - It will not create problems, I take guarantee - I will not say something that will create violence. Yes, I know there were on Non-Veg. and Veg. meat… in Ahmedabad and Gujarat… and there were riots and all. Here… as far as I am concerned, I speak logical… there will nothing happen. The brother has asked a very good question - He said that he had seen pilgrims going… and for three days, they did not have meat… they did not have meat.
(Dr. Mohammed) It is on Islam.
(Dr. Zakir) It is on Islam… It is on Islam.
(Dr. Mohammed) Why Islam allows like this? - No he has asked a question on Islam.
(Dr. Zakir) He is asking a question on Islam… he is not asking on Jainism - What is the problem? Are you so much afraid that the answer will make him a Non-Veg.? He will yet be a Veg. … no problem - I do not want you to become a Non-Veg. The Brother asked a very good question – that is… ‘Why there, do not you have
Non-Veg.?’ It is a misinformation… I have been for Haj several times - Whoever told you… told you a lie, that we do not have Non-Veg. The thing out there is, that in that sacred part, at that time, you cannot kill any animal for hunting - at that time only… but not eating Non-Veg. I have gone there… I ate Non-Veg.... who says you cannot eat Non-Veg.? Yes, we are dressed up in two pieces of unsewn cloth… you know why?… You know why? Because it is the biggest annual gathering in the world - People come of America, from Canada, from India, from Pakistan, from Indonesia - all dressed up in two pieces of unsewn cloth - Identical. You cannot make out the person next to you… whether he is a king or a pauper - For Universal brotherhood - not theoretical… practical – Universal brotherhood. When we offer Salaah, we offer Salaah… shoulder to shoulder - We eat food, we eat together - We eat even Non-Veg. Where you got this from?… I do not know - who ever told you, whether Muslim or Non-Muslim, he has told you total falsehood. I am telling you, I have been for Haj several times, I have been for Umrah - it is totally wrong. And for universal brotherhood… everyone comes there… so that you can make out people from various parts of the world - We have to be one brotherhood. Islamic brotherhood is that, all human beings are brothers - And Muslims are brothers in faith.
(Dr. Mohammed) Yes brother.
(Q) Mr. Zaveri, this question is for you - At the end of your speech, Mr. Zaveri… this question if for you please.
(Dr. Mohammed) Yes, put forward your question.
(Q). Mr. Zaveri is having his attention there - Mr. Zaveri this question is for you. At the end of your speech, you have listed 16 points differentiating between herbivorous animals and the carnivorous animals. Now I do not feel there is any one in the audience to know this differences… except that you want to give emphasis on the point that… being giving the comparison of Herbivorous animals, you want to show… you want to reflect that we humans should also be Herbivorous - that is we should be Vegetarians - This is what I understand. Dr. Zakir has already put… has already touched few of the points. Now, Dr. Zakir and Mr. Zaveri, I am not a medical student by profession - I am an engineering student. I had Biology only upto my tenth standard, and there after only I have gathered some knowledge from here and there.
(Mr. Zaveri) Ask your question please.
(Q). Now here is the points which I want to get a comment from you side is… that you have said… Pytalen is there is the saliva of Herbivorous animal - it is there in Carnivorous animals, and it is there present in the humans also. Now you have said that Herbivorous animals rotate their jaws while eating - I have never seen a man rotating his jaws.
(Mr. Zaveri) See it is a question of your… if you want to put a question, you are most welcome - It is not a lecture session - put forward your question. We are not here… to hear your impressions - you are most welcome to ask me a direct question – say… ask me a direct question - I will be too willing to give you a reply… because both Mr. Trivedi and myself… we have got other appointments - We will be leaving after this.
(Dr. Mohammed) Excuse me… excuse me.. you ask your question in three to four sentences - that is all… three to four sentences.
(Q). What was the need for you to give the differentiate… differentiation between Herbivorous and Carnivorous animals? - What do you want to emphasize?
(Mr. Zaveri) Yes.. it is sir, a very natural thing that when I stated that almost all names and parts of the body of human being, are very similar to Herbivorous animals - it is for the enlightened audience to decide whether I say… whether you agree with me or not. If you agree it is well and good - otherwise if you do not agree, then also well and good. Who am I to say that you must agree on one point or others?… that is okay. Because what I have stated, is a scientific fact which I have got reasons and I have got proof for that - But it is for the audience to see whether it is - you are agreeable to that or not. My only point was that… by nature, a human being is more… not only more… but hundred percent, he is Herbivorous - and by certain circumstances, or by other some reasons, he has been made a Carnivorous. Now friends I must tell you that I am extremely delighted to be here this morning, and sharing our views - and so many misconceptions about Islam, is now cleared by our learned Dr. Zakir. We never knew that these things are said in Islam, and for that I am extremely thankful to Islamic Research Foundation - and I am also thankful to my friend Mr. Salecha, Rushab Foundation. And because of the time constraint of Mr. Trivedi and myself… because we have got other engagements, we will take your leave - and again, thank you very much.
(Dr. Mohammed) Mr. Bade… Mr. Bade has to ask… yes you are Mr. Bade yes... now... excuse me - Mr. Bade has been requested specially to be given a chance to ask question - we have honored that request and he will be given a chance now. After that Mr. Trivedi will… last question from that side and then… yes last question, from there - ladies I think are less in number, so we disallow those two questions which were missed out. I hope that would be fair Mr. Trivedi - Yes Mr. Bade - then you… then we finish this session - Yes. Mr… Hari Om to Hindus…
(Dr. Mohammed) Arey haan .. so sorry … after we conclude the session two people will get a chance to hear Dr. Zakir. If you want to hear the answer… and those who want to hear can stay back… others can go - Yes Mr. Bade.
(Q). Har Om to Hindus… Jai Jainindra to Jains… Salaam Walaikum to Muslim Bhais…
(Dr. Mohammed) Wa Alaikum Salaam.
(Q). A request to Dr. Zakir… I have all the answers of all your 20 questions… but that will not allow… kindly give me chance any, any time you will get logical answers of all the 20 questions - number one. Now, you will… all the Religions follow the God… God is Almighty - now that means one should follow the… follow His rules also. Now what is given by the God… the rules formed up by the God… Ek seedi si baat hain - ki jab bhagwan ne hamhe janm diya hain - to unhoone hamaare liye kuch vevasta bhi kiye.
(Dr. Mohammed) Sir… sir… question… see…
(Q). I am not giving a lecture… I am no giving a….
(Dr. Mohammed) I would apply the same rule, I applied to the last speaker - put your question in five sentences. Assume Dr. Zakir and Mr. Zaveri know the background… ask your question… six sentences please.
(Q) (contd…). I am asking… I am asking you the question only. To Bhagwaan ne hammaare liye jo bhi kuch diya hain - unhooneh kuch rule form karke diye hain. Jasise ke hamaare liye sab se essential bath hain havi ki - Plenty of ‘hava’ is available… abundant ‘hava’ is available. Uske baad pani rahta hain - Pani… where ever you go… Pani is available. Now another thing is food which is… which I am coming to the question… the food… Bhagwaan has given us the food also. Ka.. ka.. Kashmir emin hain - Hamare liyeh Kashmir mein hain - Ilake ke mutahit diya hain - Kashmir mein hamaare liyeh almonds diye hain, kaju diye hain, badam diya hain, pista diye hain, jake vahaan zaruri hain - one second. Rajasthan mein javo, aapko vahaan, woh temperature ke mutabik aapko Kherbuza milenga, Tharbuza milenga. Yahaan hammare liye… one second… question… question I am telling you. Yahaan hamare liye halwa banake kele ke upar rakh diya. Or whatever easily is available. He has given us plenty. Now the… whatever He has given, is plenty… is cheaper - and whatever He says… ‘No it is not to be taken, or it is restricted’ - should be… He has made it costly. So are we following the rule of the God?
(Dr. Mohammed) Sir what is the question on this topic?
(Dr. Zakir) Very good… very good… very…
(Q) (contd…) He has understood it.
(Dr. Zakir) I have understood the question, very long question, very good question. See I am in the field… I can make out the question - I am in the field. Regarding your first part… that you can answer all 20 points - I have got various students in this field… I will ask one of my students to have a dialogue at IRF if you want - Any time… which day?… Next Sunday… next Sunday - Not me… my student - Next Sunday.
(Q). (Contd…) I can… I can answer to anybody.
(Dr. Zakir) Next Sunday.
(Q). (Contd…) Any body.
(Dr. Zakir) Next Sunday.
(Q). (Contd…) Anybody.
(Dr. Zakir) Okay done… next Sunday you are invited.
(Dr. Zakir) What is your name? Brother.. your name?
(Q). (Contd…) Everything will be given.
(Dr. Zakir) Mr. Bade will come to IRF at 10:30, fine 10:30 morning, Sunday.. same format here - and my student will debate… any one - same topic.
(Clapping)…… His question, that… ‘God has provided air, light, water, everything easily available - so why go for things which are uneasily available and costly?’ - Very good question. That… you have to point out to Mr. Zaveri - he is telling that vegetables should be transported to Arctic Circle… Vegetables should be transported to deserts. Tell him - I did not tell that - I am saying… ‘If vegetable is available… have vegetable - if animal is available… have the lawful animal - You have to pose that question to him… not to me. Point No.1 - ‘You should have easily available food, as long as it is lawful… we should not have expensive food’… You told me. It is like I telling a rich person… ‘Why are you living in Nariman Point?… You know one square feet of land-apartment in Nariman Point, costs 25,000 rupees - Come to Mira Road… only 1000 rupees per square feet’. When the rich man can afford to pay money, to buy a good flat… why are you preventing a rich man to buy good food? And Non-Veg. food… in protein, in iron, in various ways medically… it is superior, it is of higher quality - so if rich man can afford it, why are you stopping? If you cannot afford, have Vegetables. I am not stopping you - Hope that answers the question.
(Clapping) ……
(Dr. Mohammed) Thank you for your enthusiasm. We will not allow that question - Mr. Zaveri has said he would like to… he is exhausted, and we respect his views. He would like to leave… so we will not allow that question - but we will allow two people here, who were to ask questions, after Mr. Zaveri… and leave… because I had promised them. Yes… Mr. Dhanraj Salecha would propose a vote of thanks… after which, those who would like to leave, may leave - those who would will like to hear those two questions and two answers, may sit.
(Q). Excuse me… one question from the ladies side - It is not working… Hello.
(Dr. Mohammed) The meeting would be formally closed - Only two questions after the meeting would be allowed.
(Q). Hello, hello… Excuse me, this is one last question from the ladies - this is for Dr. Zakir.
(Dr. Mohammed) Hello, we will allow the… no we will... Acha… after this, those two people, and one from the ladies… and no one be… Acha… one… one, two, three, four… four questions - Excuse me, Mr. Trivedi is saying that I should be strict. Now the thing is that I being compassionate - I gave chance to two people here… now everyone is demanding of… What we will allow… vote of thanks right away - then four questions… two here… one there… one there, then close - That is final. Yes… Mr. Dhanraj Salecha to propose the vote of thanks.
(Dhanraj Salecha) Chief guest Shri Y.P. Trivedi, learned speakers of dialogue, distinguished guests, brothers and sisters… it is really my pleasant duty to offer vote of thanks on behalf of all the three organizations, on whose behalf I thank Shri Y.P. Trivedi, to spare his valuable time and grace this occasion, as chief guest. I am really thankful to both the speakers for their most interesting and informative discussion and above all I thank you all the participants, for participating in the debate - thank you.
(Dr. Mohammed) Now we continue on with the four questions - the chief guest Mr. Trivedi, Mr. Zaveri are excused. Those who would like to hear the three or four questions allowed, may sit back - we will continue in a minute, as the chief guest and the speaker leave. The formal programme is closed - we will have an informal four questions, allowed for the audiences… for the four questioners who did not get a chance, because of my interfering and giving the other speakers a chance. Ladies and gentlemen, your attention please - We are starting the sequel Question-Answer session right away - Yes brother.
(Q). My question is - are Non-Vegetarian food deficient in nutrition?
(Dr. Zakir) The brother has asked a very good question - that are Non-Vegetarian food deficient in any nutrients? Yes they are - It will be wrong on my part to say… ‘No!’ - I am not a fanatic Non-Vegetarian. It is deficient in Carbohydrates, Vitamin C - but this is easily available in vegetables – Non-Vegetarians even have vegetables, and fruits – they are rich in Vitamin C - You can have fruits, but as a normal comparison, in nutritive value, if you analyze the Non-Veg. food as I mentioned earlier… it contain first class proteins… high quality. And complete proteins contain essential fatty acids - even Iron. And one of the good food is ‘Egg’, which the speaker spoke so much against… ‘Egg’… ‘Egg’. The Egg contains about six grams of Protein - One large Egg. The half of it, is in the Egg white, and the Egg white is known as an ideal Protein. Ideal protein means - the proteins by which the other proteins are judged. It contains all the essential Amino acids in the right quantity. Egg also contains Riboflavin, Iron, Fluorine, Vitamin B12, Vitamin D, Vitamin E - One of the few only food which contain Vitamin D, is Egg. Egg is given to people who are sick and are convalescing… who are improving from sickness. You know why? - It is easily digested, contains all the requirement - Spoke so much about ‘Egg’ - has little negative factor also. It is also called a ‘Nutrient-dense food ’, -because it contains all the essential nutrients in the right quantity, without excess of any one particular substance, and contains less calorie - Contains 70 calories only… one large Egg. But there are many food, which contain essential Amino acids, which are not there in the Veg. food. In the Veg. food… what we have to do, if we require all the nutrients - A person can be a Veg. and get the nutrients… how? - By selecting the particular diet, by selecting the vegetables he is eating. If this vegetable is deficient in one Amino Acid - have the other vegetable which has it. So if he selectively chooses in the correct balance, and monitors it, then he will be healthy. In Non-Veg. food… just have any Non-Veg. food, and normally you will not be deficient in these Nutrients - Hope that answer the question.
(Dr. Mohammed) Yes brother.
(Q). My name is Babubhai Zaveri. Dr. Zakir… Dr. Zakir Naik mentioned in his speech… He tried to quote authorities alternative to Dr. Dean Ornish. Dr. Dean Ornish has.. has been a pioneer in the field of research, on reversal of heart diseases, and he has now come to be a claimed as an authority. His contribution to the field has been recognized by the President of United States, by appointing him as an advisor - to advice Americans on health matters. It is at the instance of Dr. Ornish, that now it has been incorporated in the authoritative medical text books, that heart disease can be reversed through the diet - Diet which has been practiced and preached by Dr. Ornish, and Dr… and this… this particular diet consists exclusively of Vegetarian food. Now I would like to know from Dr. Zakir Naik - when he has quoted alternative authorities… what he had to say about Dr. Dean Ornish’s research, which has cured thousands of patients of coronary... coronary disease, without By-pass Surgery?
(Dr. Zakir) Brother has asked a very good question… very relevant question, to the point - that, what do I have to speak about Dr. Ornish, who is very famous. And he has said that… ‘The heart disease can be reversed by food, which is only Vegetarian food’ - I agree. Does it make Non-Veg. food, prohibited? Do you know ‘Diabetes Maltese’ - brother… ‘Diabetes Maltese’. You do not require Dr. Ornish to say… ‘If a person is suffering from diabetes, severe ‘Diabetes Maltese’ - if he does not take Non-Veg... treatment of Insulin produced by ‘Bovine’… by pancreas of cow or of pig, or human being, he will die’. So if a Non-Veg. food can cure ‘Diabetes Maltese’… that does not make Veg. prohibited - I agree with Dr. Ornish. It proves that heart diseases can be prevented or cured, by Veg. diet - I agree. But what Mr. Rashmibhai Zaveri said… ‘‘Dr. Ornish said… ‘it should be prohibited’ ’’. As a general rule for heart patients, I agree - People may differ… Many doctors may differ - I agree… I agree. But to say… ‘Because it cures heart disease, Non-Veg. should be prohibited, as a general rule’ - then why is not America banning Non-Veg. food? - Advisor it to American government… Advisor to American government. Why does not the government take the advise of Dr. Ornish, and stop Non-Veg. food - Why? What his research is… if he is authority, he is right - But to quote the authority, and then say… ‘he banned it’. I doubt whether Dr. Ornish even banned it - I doubt… I have my doubts. Show me the statement where it says that… ‘No human being ever in this life, should not have any Non-Veg. food?’ - I challenge you… I challenge you. He may say… ‘Heart patients’. There are other authorities, I quoted… Dr. William. T. Jarves, Dr. K. Jerry… several… several. But I am more… more pragmatic - I agree with him, it is helpful in curing heart disease… not as a general rule. Hope that answers the question - I am very clear.
( Dr. Mohammed ) Yes sister.
(Q). This is regarding… since Dr. Zakir is a scientist and a doctor himself - so I would like him to enlighten me, on the 15 years of clinical trial on…
(Dr. Mohammed) I did not get the question - Can you repeat the question.
(Q) (contd…) 15 years of clinical trial at the National Cancer Research Institute, at Meriland, in USA, on this Red meat… ‘Red meat causes cancer and all those things’. Is it… is it possible for him to enlighten me on this? - Thank You.
(Dr. Zakir) It is a very question - Sister said… ‘Out of 15 years of research in some Cancer Hospital’. ‘Research’ again… not ‘Fact’. There is a difference between ‘Research’… and ‘Fact’. But I agree with that research also… I have read that research - Whether from Cancer Hospital or which Hospital, which she is referring to. I have read several research, that it does cause ‘Cancer of the Colon’. Excessive eating of Non-Veg. causes ‘Cancer of Colon’, if it does not contain diet, rich in fibre. If the diet is rich is fibre, however much meat you have, it will not cause cancer… if it is combined with excessive eating of Non-Veg., and lack of fibrous diet. You know Veg. food… you eat… it cannot be digested because, the cellulose cannot be digested - it remains as fibre, which helps in the motility. Excessive eating of Non-Veg. With not eating fibrous diet causes ‘Cancer of Colon’ - but if you have the proper combination, everyone having Red meat… does not have cancer. Excessive eating… Qur’an says its haram. So they are going against the Qur’an… they are bound to get diseases. That does not mean Non-Veg. is prohibited - it should be said… ‘Excessive eating of Non-Veg., should be prohibited’. Hope that answers the question. Wa Aakhira Dawana Anil Hamdulillahi Rabbil Alameen.
(Dr. Mohammed) Thank you very much… JazakAllah Khairan, for being here today, and sharing your Sunday morning with us. InshaAllah, we will be in touch with you.
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
Today, there have been 12 visitors (14 hits) on this page! |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
